Amherst Police Department
The Amherst Police Department. Credit: GAZETTE FILE PHOTO

AMHERST — Kimberly DeBlase asked first for an American Sign Language interpreter, someone to convey information throughout the booking process in a medium she could understand.

On Halloween 2023, DeBlase, who is deaf, had taken her two children trick-or-treating with their father, put them to bed and gone to visit him in his unit in the same Amherst apartment complex, according to a federal lawsuit she has since filed. As the children slept, a domestic disturbance broke out, the complaint states. Amherst police arrested DeBlase that night, charging her with disorderly conduct, breaking and entering, and assault and battery on a family or household member.

Three years later, DeBlase is alleging in a lawsuit filed Oct. 30 in U.S. District Court in Springfield that, while she was in their custody, Amherst police refused her an interpreter, as well as access to the MassRelay Service, whose operators are trained to assist the deaf and hard of hearing with communicating.

According to the lawsuit, officers allowed DeBlase to FaceTime her sister, who interpreted in British Sign Language, but “the police decided that they did not agree with the advice […] and decided to terminate the call.”

Frustrated attempts at communication form the basis of DeBlase’s civil complaint against the town of Amherst, the Amherst Police Department and four police officers, two named and two unidentified. It alleges that, in detaining DeBlase, Amherst police used excessive force and violated the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), the state’s public accommodation law, and DeBlase’s civil rights under state law.

“They failed to have a policy in place to address these situations. If they did have a policy in place, the police officers on duty didn’t know what it was or chose not to follow that policy. It’s certainly something that need not have happened,” DeBlase’s attorney, Alfred Chamberland, told the Gazette.

The Amherst Police Department enacted a policy for communicating with people who are deaf or hard of hearing this March, two and a half years after DeBlase’s arrest, that “establishes procedures for identifying communication needs and for providing appropriate auxiliary aids and services,” according to Town Manager Paul Bockelman.

Bockelman said in a statement that the town had not been notified of the lawsuit before the Gazette’s inquiry but that it is in the process of reviewing it. Amherst Police Chief Gabriel Ting could not be reached for comment.

“Everyone in our community deserves to feel safe and respected. The town and the Police Department take all reported concerns seriously and are committed to ensuring all of our policies and practices are consistent with our legal obligations and our commitment to serving every member of the community,” Bockelman said.

DeBlase is requesting $5 million in relief.

What the ADA requires

At various junctures in their interactions with people with disabilities, law enforcement officers may encounter the need to reasonably modify their practices to avoid discrimination, as Title II of the ADA requires of state and local governments and their criminal justice agencies, according to the Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Division.

A suspect with an intellectual disability might be prompted to repeat back to arresting officers each sentence of the Miranda warning in their own words to ensure they understand their rights. In the case of deaf arrestees, officers might handcuff the person in front of their body so they can communicate using handwritten notes or sign language.

Under Title II, law enforcement must give primary consideration to the accommodation the person requests and ultimately “take appropriate steps to ensure that communication with people with disabilities is as effective as communication with people without disabilities.” In the case of deaf detainees, police must ensure that their communication is as effective as it would be with a hearing person, the DOJ site states.

Kathy Gips, director of training at the New England ADA Center, spoke generally about the law’s requirements and did not comment on DeBlase’s case.

“If ultimately the department believes that communication is effective by writing or typing, a text-based communication, that would be OK. That’s a judgment call: Has communication been effective?” Gips said.

Gips said providing ASL interpretation generally should not place an undue burden on police departments or require extraordinary efforts. MassRelay, a digital service DeBlase alleges she asked for but was refused, operates 24/7 and adapts to any device with a camera. A neutral, confidential interlocutor could have signed to DeBlase on officers’ behalf and spoken her responses aloud.

Chamberland said officers attempted to communicate with DeBlase in writing but “that wasn’t effective.” DeBlase is somewhat verbal, he said, but her speech can become especially difficult to understand under distressing conditions.

“The final decision is up to the municipality, but it does have to be effective,” Gips said. “That’s the key piece of it.”

Understanding DeBlase’s experience

On the evening of Oct. 31, 2023, Amherst police responded twice to the apartment complex where DeBlase lived with her children, according to the lawsuit. Their father lived in the same complex but in a separate apartment. At first, officers opted not to make any arrests but returned within an hour after receiving another call about a disturbance, the complaint states.

“At the time that police were dispatched, they were aware that Plaintiff was deaf and used ASL to communicate,” the lawsuit states. “The arresting officer did not know ASL and the police did not dispatch any person that knew ASL.”

The father of DeBlase’s children was not arrested on any charges that evening, according to her attorney.

In the booking room at the Amherst Police Department, DeBlase alleges, she was shoved into a corner and had her phone seized. In the holding cell, after she laced her nylon leggings and two other articles of clothing around her neck, simulating strangulation, DeBlase says police pinned her to a cement bench and stripped her bare, leaving her curled on the floor and in tears, the lawsuit alleges. Forty minutes later, a police officer brought a blanket to cover her naked body, according to the complaint.

Afterward, Chamberland said, DeBlase was transported to an area hospital for mental health treatment.

Her episode in police custody caused DeBlase “extraordinary emotional distress and post-traumatic stress,” the complaint states. “The force that was used to remove the Plaintiff’s clothing and actions of the officers to leave her naked was extreme, unnecessary and excessive.”

The altercation in the cell was the outgrowth of failed communication, the suit contends. Officers were “frustrated and exasperated” and, consequently, brought two additional charges against her of assault and battery on a police officer, the lawsuit states.

Of the charges facing DeBlase that evening, two went to trial, where juries found her not guilty of disorderly conduct and assault and battery on a police officer, according to the lawsuit, which also states that all other charges were dismissed before trial. Court documents in DeBlase’s cases are sealed, and details about the disposition of the case could not be independently corroborated.

“I’m dumbfounded that a town that puts itself out as such a progressive town as Amherst would fall so low below the standards,” said Chamberland, who also represented DeBlase in the criminal proceedings.

Rebeca Pereira is a deputy news editor / reporter at the Daily Hampshire Gazette. She can be reached at rpereira@gazettenet.com.