As a professional historian, a member of the Sierra Club and a volunteer in the Citizens’ Climate Lobby, I urge environmentalists, historic preservationists and progressive voters in Massachusetts to support the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA).
This bill takes a wider definition of federal jurisdiction than Republicans want while also raising the due-diligence standards for historic preservation, speeding up the rollout of clean energy infrastructure and lowering energy costs for working people in Massachusetts.
It addresses that energy prices are now unnecessarily high because, even though wind and solar are the cheapest form of energy in 85% of the United States, 93% of the permits stuck in federal court are for clean energy infrastructure. Citizens Climate Lobby estimates that even waiting one year to pass a better bill will do more damage to the climate than passing this bipartisan bill now. President Donald Trump is far less likely to sign a permitting reform and affordability bill passed by Democrats than a one with bipartisan support now. Democrats should not delay this bill and wait a highly uncertain two years and through the next presidential election to pass perhaps a better one by Democrats.
To both preserve the cultural heritage of North America and speed the energy-infrastructure permitting process, the bill makes a comprise. It affirms states have the right to pass and enforce their own laws on historical preservation on state-owned lands and private property. If a bulldozer wrecks a historic site in a state forest or on a privately held farm, the plaintiffs may not sue in federal court. Democrats got the term “federally controlled land” instead of “federal land,” a wider definition of lands some courts ruled currently under federal protection. In return, Republicans got confirmation that plaintiffs may not sue in federal court for damages on state land or private property. The co-sponsors, Senators Whitehouse (D-RI), Heinrich (D-NM), and Capito (R-WV) and Lee (R-UT), aim further to make developers take responsibility for historical preservation before the bulldozers wreck sites. The bill raises the standards for due diligence when developers site power lines, which will span thousands of miles, take years to plan and, in New England, cross state lines and the border with Canada. The co-sponsors truly want to both speed energy-infrastructure builds and preserve cultural heritage. The Democrats, Whitehouse and Heinrich, promise to modify the bill in the next Congress if these safeguards on historic preservation fall short.
As both a volunteer in Citizens’ Climate Lobby and a dues-paying member of Sierra Club of western Massachusetts, I am concerned that wealthy members in eastern Massachusetts funded an army of professional lobbyists to kill this bill. By insisting on its own narrow priorities, Sierra Club supports taxing ratepayers with higher electricity prices. Sierra Club puts the burden of the high costs of energy on farmers, tradesmen and small business owners. These are the largest group of workers in my congressional district, MA-02, and they want lower energy prices.
I hope our U.S. Senators Elisabeth Warren and Ed Markey and Congressman Jim McGovern support the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. The bill addresses the needs of working people in Massachusetts by promising lower energy costs. It secures jobs for Massachusetts workers. If our Massachusetts congressional delegation rejects this bill, they should expect to face disappointed veterans, tradesmen and small business owners, some of my personal friends, who voted Republican in 2024 and Democrat in 2026.
I hope McGovern, Warren and Markey care about the working people of western Massachusetts and support this bill.
Andrew Donson is a volunteer with the Pioneer Valley Chapter of the Citizens’ Climate Lobby and lives in Northampton.
