Every year, at about this time, people start thinking about putting out food for the birds. For some people this decision is largely dictated by the presence of black bears in their neighborhoods, and it can be a tricky one to make. If there have been no feeders hanging out for the entire summer, when is the best moment to put them back? If the feeders are out too early, will the bears show up and destroy everything? If the feeders are only put out during the daytime, will they be safe from marauders? It’s a diabolical decision that needs to be made with the understanding that every year is different. There is no perfect answer.

For the most part, you are probably safe if you wait until the first snow flies. Looking back at my own personal records (stretching back to the winter of 2011-12) I see that at my house the earliest first snow of the season fell on October 17, 2015. The latest first snow of the season fell on Nov. 24, 2012. That also happened to be a “year without a winter,” with virtually no snow in 2012-13 at all. If we look at the average, then we are a bit behind schedule in 2026-27, but every year is different. Who knows what is going to happen?

So, I think that it is prudent to start planning your feeding station at your house. Nancy, one of my dear friends from the Berkshires, has informed me of her wish to buy one of those fancy 4-tube birdfeeders that can offer a wide selection to her backyard birds. This is a great idea, and I am motivated to help. So, without further ado, let’s look at the choices.

The “King” of birdseed is the sunflower seed, and it is important to realize that there are actually two varieties of sunflower seeds that can be procured in pure bags or in mixed bags. First is the black oil sunflower seed (#1), known for its smaller size and more delicate black shells. The other sunflower is the Gray Striped, which is much larger with a thicker shell. This variety is the one that is offered as “shelled” sunflower seed (#2). The Safflower (not pictured) has plump white seeds and is rather expensive.

Next is the humble peanut (#3), which is going to be extraordinarily popular with blue jays. If left on the ground, or a deck railing, peanuts will be almost instantly grabbed and spirited away by the jays. Only by offering them up in special tube feeders built out of hardware cloth will the woodpeckers get a shot at them. If you love woodpeckers as I do, then you might consider picking up one of these feeders for your collection.

Another very popular seed is White Millet (#4), which is made available in bags of mixed seed. This is a small, spherical seed that is exceptionally attractive to mourning doves and the various sparrows that tend to focus on seeds that have been spread out on the ground. Take care when buying bags of mixed seed because you want to avoid a type of seed called “milo.” Larger than millet, and more red in color, this is an inexpensive “filler” that is always the last seed left over. Most of the birds in my yard just aren’t interested in milo. The milo-free blends are a little more expensive, but there isn’t any waste. Many seed blends also contain cracked corn (the larger chunks in #4) that are popular with Mourning Doves.

Finally, there is the Nyger seed, which is often advertised as “thistle” seed. There are several species of thistles that live in North America; some native and some invasive, depending on where you live. Thistle plants produce tiny black seeds that are attached to downy white parachutes that help them to spread across the landscape. These seeds are extremely popular with finches, but they are only available in late summer.

Thistle farming is impractical, but there is a plant called the Nyger plant (Guizotia abyssinica), which is a cousin of the sunflower and is native to the highlands of Ethiopia. This plant produces seeds that are extremely small and bear a striking resemblance to the Black Oil Sunflower. These seeds are also wildly popular with finches, but they require specialized feeders. Tubes made from fine metal mesh can hold the seeds in place while finches tweeze them out of hiding. Another type of feeder is simply referred to as a “sock.” This is an inexpensive fabric bag that has small holes woven into it so that finches can get at the seeds. The metal feeders are more expensive, but squirrels cannot destroy them.

So, with all these choices, which is the best one? Well, that will be a decision that you have to make that depends on your unique yard. All of these seeds can be offered in long cylindrical feeders called “tube” feeders, but the White Millet would be a poor choice here. The sparrows and mourning doves that love millet will not happily visit tube feeders, so mixed seed is best offered by spreading it on the ground, your deck, or deck railings. Just be cautious. Cats can wreak havoc on birds, so if you have cats lurking in your neighborhood, you might only spread the mixed seeds where there are no objects that might offer ambush positions for cats.

The sunflower seeds will be eaten by anyone who can get hold of them. This includes squirrels, so be prepared to share some of your birdseed with hungry mammals. Sunflower seeds that are placed into squirrel-proof feeders will go directly to the birds, but I don’t have room here to get into the various squirrel-proof designs. Some are better than others, but the good ones are pricey.

The specialty seeds — peanuts and nyger — require specialty feeders, but the response that you get will be worth the expense. However, I would recommend that you first try a thistle sock to see if you get any customers. Once you have a large clientele, then you can invest in one of the more expensive wire-mesh tube feeders. It all boils down to your particular yard, your particular viewing opportunities, and your particular budget. Do what feels right and enjoy the little community of birds that will gather at your home for whatever TLC you can provide.

Bill Danielson has been a professional writer and nature photographer for 29 years. He has
worked for the National Park Service, the U.S. Forest Service, the Nature Conservancy and the Massachusetts State Parks and he currently teaches high school biology. For more information visit www.speakingofnature.com, Speaking of Nature on Facebook, or the Speaking of Nature Podcast (Season 2 coming soon).