Serena and Venus Williams, Palm Beach, Florida, 2016. From “WOMEN: New Portraits”
Serena and Venus Williams, Palm Beach, Florida, 2016. From “WOMEN: New Portraits” Credit: ©ANNIE LEIBOVITZ

I had the privilege of attending photographer Annie Leibovitz’s opening of her exhibit in New York City titled “WOMEN: New Portraits.”

The exhibit is in the prison gymnasium of the former Bayview
Correctional Facility, a women’s prison until just four years ago, which is now on its way to becoming a women’s building of New York City. We shared the space with former inmates who attended as guests. Immediately inspiring.

Annie partnered with Gloria Steinem in this 10-city, three-continent tour, and the opening events include a “talking circle,” or opportunity to have a freewheeling conversation. This one, occurring just a week after the election, kept returning to the question of where to go from here.

The discussion was good. The words from the former inmates were powerful. But what inspires me to write are Gloria’s closing words.

I paraphrase liberally:

This difficult moment is actually a reflection of our progress, explained Gloria, who used to be one of 12 women shouting to be heard from the back of the room. Now Hillary will win the popular vote by over two million votes. For women (and people of color and LGBTQ), possibilities are now immeasurably (and measurably) greater. That is a whole lot of progress.

She continued: Trump’s candidacy and looming presidency has given permission to a small but terrifying portion of our population who are haters of immigrants, people of color, gays and lesbians, women, Jews, people with disabilities, all who are defined as “other” from those who hate. This scares us a lot. To help manage the fear, Gloria offered an analogy:

In a domestic abuse situation, the most dangerous time is when the victim is at the threshold of leaving the abuser. The abuser senses the loss of control and lashes out in a desperate attempt to regain it.

For the haters in our midst, we as a nation are leaving them. Our country’s color and cultures have changed and will keep changing. There is fear and resistance in response, which also makes for real danger. We must be extremely vigilant and protective as the change continues.

And to complete the analogy with vigilance in tow – next up is newfound freedom. And safety.

I love that vision for the hope it contains, the endurance it requires.

I began writing these words three weeks ago, first as an email to friends, inspired to share that which inspired me, typing furiously on my phone on the Metro North train home from New York City.

Since that time two things have happened that only strengthen this initial inspiration. First, I saw Richard Spencer, the white supremacist, shout “Hail Trump” at a conference of 200 people in a federal building, videotaped for the world to see and hear. I heard him speak of how whites are destined “to conquer” and I saw other conference-goers respond with the Nazi salute.

Secondly, I visited the National Museum of African American History and Culture in Washington, D.C. I saw in the boldest relief possible the centuries of devastating oppression and brutality, alongside never-ending resistance and unfathomable courage. There in those halls lay testimony to the greatest extremes of what we humans are capable of, all of which resides within each of us as part of our country’s history.

We must study that history, the shame and the triumph, and draw on it right now as we marshal our resources. I believe that is our greatest duty to all who suffered so unjustly before us. We must ensure that neither Nazi salutes nor vestiges of slavery find refuge in our democracy.

Since Trump’s election, our senses are hit daily with more reason for fear of what’s coming next. His appointments, his tweets, his contortions of truth so what is impossible to defend becomes impossibly defensible. We are being tested and his presidency has not even begun yet.

We know what to do. All the people and struggles that have become before us offer that gut-level clarity. We organize. We strategize. We protest. We demand justice for those wrongfully denied. History teaches us there is no other way.

On that day in the former Bayview Correctional Facility, Gloria reminded us that to show up, to protect each other and the ideals on which this country was founded, is to claim hope. It is ours for the taking.

Thank you, Annie Leibovitz, for bringing us the visceral power of women.

Thank you, Gloria Steinem, for providing us the living history that strengthens all of our faith and resolve to make the change that lies ahead.

Annie Leibovitz’s “WOMEN: New Portraits” exhibit is showing through Dec. 11 at the former Bayview Correctional Facility, 550 West 20th St. (between 10th and West Streets), Wednesday, Saturday and Sunday from 10 a.m. to 7 p.m., and Thursday and Friday from 10 a.m. to 8 p.m. It is open to the public free of charge, courtesy of the exhibit’s sponsor UBS.

Activist Pamela Schwartz, a former Northampton city councilor, is director of the Western Massachusetts Network to end Homelessness.