We had a full dinner table when I was a kid. There were three girls, four boys, each about two years apart, with our mother and father attempting to keep our bottoms in our chairs and our food on our plates.
My mother didn’t really like to cook, but she managed to feed nine people every night and we cleaned our plates.
Milk was spilled and food was sometimes scarce. We argued about who got more and why did we have to eat peas. But we gathered every night at 7 p.m. as a family. We talked about what we did that day at school and what we had read in the paper about the world outside our neighborhood. We learned how to dine in the company of others.
Of course there were rules: don’t slide the milk across the (very wide) table, don’t take food off someone else’s plate, and no elbows on the table. If you don’t have something nice to say, then don’t say anything at all. And my favorite — no singing at the table. All of these rules were broken on more than one occasion, but we attempted to behave.
My parents used a variety of methods to reinforce their expectations, including humor, the occasional tap on the misplaced elbow with a spoon, or sometimes exile for the most egregious offenses.
My father would say, “Would you behave this way if you were invited to eat at the White House?” And of course our answer was that we would never be invited to dinner at the White House but, if we were, we would certainly know how to act. We all knew that it was a fanciful idea, but the message was that dinner at the White House was something to aspire to and that everyone is on their best behavior when dining with the president.
I often wonder what my father would say about Donald Trump as the occupant of the White House. While he was a lifelong New Deal/New Frontier Democrat, he respected politicians with principles, Republican or Democrat. And he respected the office of the president, even when he didn’t care for the occupant. The idea of a President Trump would have sorely tested that respect.
Throughout the 2016 campaign, Trump pushed the bounds of propriety on a regular basis. He called on his crowds to rough up reporters and protesters. He led his supporters in chants of “lock her up” and he repeatedly interrupted Hillary Clinton during the presidential debates.
Becoming president, despite the hopes even of his opponents, has not really changed him. Trump didn’t shake hands with Angela Merkel when she visited the White House, and just this week he pushed aside the prime minister of Montenegro as he raced toward the camera.
Trump blames his predecessor for his own failings and uses Twitter to vent his rage in the small hours of the morning when his handlers can’t stop him. On his inauguration day, he left his wife at the foot of the stairs as he charged ahead to meet President and Mrs. Obama at the door.
The president kowtows to authoritarian leaders like Putin, Erdoğan, and King Salman while disrespecting our democratically elected allies. He discredits the mainstream media while using fake news to further his own agenda. His boorish behavior and loose connection to facts has diminished the United States in world opinion.
But why does this matter? We already know this and after all, as he repeatedly tells us, he won! Well, it matters because he is not the first and he won’t be the last president. Each of them have certainly brought their own style and personality to the job, but they respected the office and the role of the president as the leader of the oldest and largest constitutional democracy in the world.
This week the president put out his budget for fiscal year 2018. The draconian cuts in his proposal would affect the poor, the disabled, the elderly, and children. His budget cuts SNAP (food stamps) by 25 percent and cuts fuel assistance entirely. “Trumpcare” could throw as many as 23 million people off health care while shoveling tax breaks into the pockets of people who need them the least.
After he is gone, the next president will have to repair our relationships with the rest of the world, restore the credibility of the presidency with the people of this country and rebuild the role of the federal government as the equalizing force for the poor.
At Trump’s White House dinners, he gets two scoops of ice cream with his pie while the other guests get one. That says it all.
Clare Higgins, of Northampton, a former mayor of the city, is executive director of the nonprofit Community Action! of the Franklin, Hampshire and North Quabbin Regions.
