A train in Switzerland.
A train in Switzerland. Credit: Gian Ehrenzeller/Keystone via AP

Upon reading Josh Silver’s lament in the Gazette (“Grateful for train service, but 2 problems need fixed,” Sept. 19) about the sad state of affairs we find ourselves in with regard to public transportation here in western Massachusetts — make that the entire state, no actually the entire nation — and while reading the current spate of articles on the climate crisis in general, I was driven to submit what I hope to be constructive opinions to ameliorate one of the problems we face in this area.

It’s one thing to complain. Raising one’s voice is useful, but offering suggestions to help alleviate a problem is even better. During the past several years, I have submitted many articles to various publications which have dealt with the miserable condition in which our public transportation system finds itself — both locally and nationally.

I spend a considerable amount of time in Switzerland every year, which undoubtedly boasts one of the most extensive, convenient, affordable, and remarkably “Swiss”— by that I mean efficient, dependable and squeaky clean — public conveyance schemes in the world.

I find myself presently in the tiny Swiss village of Embd (population 331), in the Swiss Canton Valais. It is precariously perched on the edge of a cliff overlooking the Vispa River, which carves out the Matter Valley. The hamlet is 5,500 feet above sea level. I got here by the only method available at this time of year — an aerial tram, which is part of the Swiss public transportation system.

The political antics performed by our politicians to get a train or two to run between Springfield and points north, south, east and west (and not very efficiently I might add) are seen as farcical by those I speak with here in Switzerland. Banner headlines are strewn across the front pages of area newspapers and politicians pat themselves on the back for achieving something we had previously accomplished by the end of the 19th century — trains connecting towns and cities across the nation!

Now I am not a civil engineer, but it doesn’t take a genius to realize that we could possibly learn something about rail travel (and other forms of public transportation) by sending a group of our “experts” to Switzerland to learn a thing or two about this enterprise. After all, that country constructed the steepest rack railway in the world in 1889 with a 48% gradient in places. It is still running flawlessly.

They have also built the world’s steepest funicular railway with gradients reaching 110%. In addition, the trains which crisscross this landscape travel through some of the most picturesque scenery imaginable. There are no “graveyards of rusted automobiles” to be seen, as crooned by Arlo Guthrie, on the “City of New Orleans.” That’s because everyone uses the train! What a boon for the environment!

What’s more, the entire national network runs like a clock — a Swiss clock! At each and every train station there is a large Mondaine clock with a second hand that pauses for two seconds on the 12, then jumps ahead to resume its precise excursion around the dial. Why you might ask? It’s in order for every clock in the system to synchronize with the master clock — every minute!

I’m actually not even sure if the trains run by the clock or if the clock runs by the trains! If a train does happen to be a minute or so late, a live voice comes on the intercom to apologize for the inconvenience and to let everyone know when the disruption will be cleared up.

I don’t mean to give the reader the impression that the Swiss network is without its flaws. The system is so complicated that virtually nobody understands it completely. The recently appointed head of the board of directors of the entire organization was unable to figure out which ticket to buy to get herself home after work!

No worries. The Swiss have that one covered. They rarely have a “controller” walk through the train to check for tickets. If by some remote chance, you do get caught with the incorrect ticket — or heaven forbid no ticket — a sufficiently contrite apology will get you by. Although I believe that these rules may be on the books, I think they are only acting as deterrents and haven’t been enforced yet.

OK, let’s not get ahead of ourselves. We can start at a more feasible level. May I suggest an electric bus that begins its route in Westhampton, stops at strategic places in Northampton, Easthampton and Southampton and finally completes its run at the newly renovated transportation complex in Springfield.

All that place needs now to make it useful are a few modes of transportation passing through! Too radical? OK. We can start with a van. Once that raises our “F” grade on polluted air quality in Hampshire County to a D-, we might even expand our horizons and hook up other towns across the state via rail, bus, tram. Then other states would join in the fun and eventually we might even get a full schedule of international routes so we could get to the Calgary Stampede and the Festival de Mexico!

I would suggest figuring out a feasible way of collecting fares, however. Sorry, I got a bit carried away daydreaming. I have to stop here, because I want to catch the 10 a.m. express to Schupfheim up the line a bit. I would like to watch the festival they are having today. I’m not too concerned though, because if I miss it, I can always board the 10:35.

Don’t forget to fill your gas tanks and check your oil. Have a nice day.

Jonathan Kahane lives in Westhampton.