As my home state this week is roundly criticized for its handling of caucus voting results, my mantra has become: “Keep calm. And love Iowa.”
I’m a transplanted Iowan who believes from the bottom of my heart that voters there deserve their first-in-the-nation voting position because of how seriously they take the responsibility.
And I was reminded of that again this year as I reveled in New York Times Iowa datelines (Burlington! What Cheer! West Des Moines!) and texted with my high school classmates who’ve been seeing and talking with Democratic candidates for months.
One attended multiple house parties in Davenport and told me several months ago that she was undecided “because I’ve only heard Pete (Buttigieg) twice,” while she’d heard the other candidates many times.
Another attended a Biden rally in Burlington, in part “because my Aunt Alsace loved Joe.” She reported that as the rally was set to begin, two of our school mates drove by the venue in a convertible with a huge Trump flag flying from the car, but those inside the venue were undeterred.
I know Iowa folks who make a point to see every candidate in the race — including those in single digits like Andrew Yang, “even if I have to drive 20 miles,” because that’s about as far as anyone in Iowa’s 99 counties has to go to accomplish that goal.
They have coffee with one candidate in the morning, eat tenderloins the size of dinner plates with another at lunch time and drink lemonade at a local church in the evening with a third.
The lucky ones even got to sample the hot dish that Amy Klobuchar served at neighborhood potlucks — a huge casserole seemingly covered with tater tots.
My sister has a great story to illustrate this point. She once ran into former presidential candidate John Edwards in an airport, and “we got talking,” as Iowans tend to do. Edwards asked her where she was from. “Southeast Iowa,” she said.
“No,” Edwards responded, “where are you from?” She tried again: “Near Burlington.” Edwards again said, “No, where are you FROM?”
She then told him she was from a little town with a population of 1,800 — Mediapolis. “I’ve been there,” he said.
Even my friends who didn’t see all the candidates in person this year still answered their doors and picked up their phones to hear cases made by their surrogates about why Elizabeth Warren or Bernie Sanders were the best choices.
And yet, after all the time they spent listening in church basements, school gymnasiums, the local diner and their own homes, I was struck this year by how many of them remained undecided. Some were still undecided even as they entered their caucus locations in one of Iowa’s more than 1,600 precincts. They literally did not know which candidate’s sign they would stand by or — if they were lucky — sit under.
I was texting with some of them as the process began. A close friend messaged me as she went out her door: “Still haven’t decided. Leaning toward Joe. Also like Amy, Pete and Andrew. Like Elizabeth a bit too.” At that point, she had less than a mile drive to make up her mind.
The local gym was a beehive of activity when she arrived. She sat at Joe’s table, even though it wasn’t immediately clear he’d have the necessary 15% of those attending to be viable. In the end, he did. Final totals from her precinct were: Bernie (33), Elizabeth and Pete (19), Joe (16), Amy (11), Steyer (2) and one uncommitted.
Who is that uncommitted voter, I wondered, and how did he or she withstand the entreaties of the captains of every other candidate’s group to join them? How might his uncommitted status affect his relationships the next day and the day after that?
While I was texting with my friends, I was also following on Facebook the live video posted by my former student, now a Washington Post reporter, who was covering the first caucus conducted simultaneously in English and Spanish in Des Moines. It too was packed with eager, excited voters.
My hometown of Mediapolis, which caucused in my high school gym and lunchroom, put Biden in first place, followed by Buttigieg. When the results were posted in the Mediapolis News, Trump supporters commented, suggesting it didn’t matter who their neighbors supported because the president would win anyway. All of these people would be working together the next day, hopefully demonstrating that “Iowa nice” quality for which we’re famous.
All of this is by way of saying Iowa is the bedrock of participatory democracy, and you can’t blame Iowans for the chaos that ensued once votes began to be reported. That was the fault of a new app — an app that couldn’t be easily downloaded or utilized.
Maybe the precinct captains should have brought their grandchildren to help them with the technology, but the point is: they did their jobs, like they always do. Not their fault that they were on hold for 90 minutes trying to report their results by phone, as they always had.
But Iowans are smart and resourceful, and they had arranged for all votes to be documented — on paper. Those votes will be reported and, most importantly, those reports will be accurate. Because Iowans like to do things right.
In the meantime, while Iowa is being hammered by, seemingly, everyone, I hope everyone will remember that my state is the epicenter of high school girls basketball and the home of the Everly Brothers, the Iowa State Fair’s life-size cow made from butter and first-in-the-nation voting.
And I hope it stays that way.
Karen List is a journalism professor at UMass Amherst.
