I am writing in response to Emilia H. Tamayo’s letter in support of the removal of Billy Park’s lawn sign. I completely agree with Emilia’s statement that the “MAGA hat represents a platform built on racism and divisiveness,” but I disagree with the actions of Zahara Ashe-Summer in taking that which she found offensive. Offensive speech is still speech guaranteed by First Amendment free speech protections, and this sign was on Park’s property, not in a public space. There are many other actions Ashe-Summer could have taken to make her (valid) points.
I believe that removing the sign may potentially aid the MAGA cause. For example, it may help persuade those that are “on the fence” about who to support in the 2020 presidential election to vote for Trump. We must fight racism in all its manifestations, but also find ways to respect the expressions of others. And we need to work to remove Trump from office, by protesting his heinous actions, and ultimately by voting him out — but not by deciding to squelch the free expression of others.
Doron Goldman
Northampton