The building currently occupied by Pizza Factory where a marijuana dispensary is proposed on the corner of Main and North Maple streets Tuesday in Florence.
The building currently occupied by Pizza Factory where a marijuana dispensary is proposed on the corner of Main and North Maple streets Tuesday in Florence. Credit: GAZETTE file photo

As a Florence resident and chair of the victorious 2016 marijuana legalization campaign committee, I feel compelled to weigh in on the controversy surrounding attempts by a father-son team from Connecticut, Richard and Marco Aranzullo, to open a retail marijuana shop called Euphorium at Florence corner, where the Pizza Factory is now located.

The controversy erupted on Aug. 15, in the parking lot behind the pizza shop, when well over a hundred people turned out for a community outreach meeting, one of the first steps in the process for obtaining a marijuana license. The purpose of meeting is to give the public an opportunity to meet the principals of the enterprise, hear their plans, and ask questions.

Since legal commerce in marijuana ceased being a novelty, these meetings have become ho-hum, pro forma affairs, typically attracting only a handful of neighbors, usually friendly. I’ve seen them convene and conclude before the coffee got cold.

Not this one. The turnout was big and the tone vitriolic, an extraordinary departure from the civility one has come to expect in local public forums. (Someone called it a “pitchfork crowd.”) Exacerbating the frustration of participants was the lack of a decent sound system. Even the Zoom connection, I later learned, conked out.

Some attendees thought cannabis should not be sold there because nearby are treatment centers visited regularly by people with serious substance abuse problems. Some were dismayed to see the Pizza Factory go, appalled that Euphorium was pushing them out (they aren’t). Is JFK Middle School, .75 miles away, too close? More than a handful said they were OK with legal marijuana generally, even voted for Question 4 in 2016, but just didn’t want to see it sold on that corner. That Northampton has “enough” cannabis shops was met with wild acclamation.

Notably, what was missing at the Aug. 15 gathering, and in subsequent writings to the Gazette, was any real evidence that the opening of a retail marijuana store could have a negative impact on the public heath or public safety, or any evidence that Euphorium was not 100% in compliance with city zoning. Sure, the sensibilities of some people may be offended, but the law does not exist to defend sensibilities: it exists to keep us safe and healthy, and to protect our rights.

Northampton’s spirit of tolerance has allowed the cannabis industry to take strong root, providing, among other positive benefits, some $5 million in new revenue, with no visible downside, except for the traffic jam on NETA’s opening day in 2017 (and perhaps the cost of counting the money). Certainly there are improvident adults and young people who don’t understand responsible use, but marijuana’s most remarkable and unspoken quality is its relative benignity, a hard thing for some to acknowledge, as it contradicts generations of anti-pot government propaganda deployed to justify and perpetuate the racism of prohibition and the war waged in its enforcement.

In 2008, Northampton voters helped decriminalize marijuana by 77%, 12 points over the state majority of 65%. In 2012, 75% of us joined 65% of Bay Staters to give adult patients access to medical marijuana. In 2016, 77% of us said “Yes” to full adult legalization, well ahead of the state average of 53.7%. Since then, Northampton has entered into 37 host community agreements with cannabis operators, of which 14 are for adult retail.

Like many, I’m astonished at the ubiquity of marijuana retailers in Northampton, but whether Northampton can support another is a question best left to investors like the Aranzullos, who are betting on us.

This dustup can be worked out. Euphorium should hold another meeting, this time in a good setting where everyone can speak and be heard. The opponents should avoid raising irrelevant or already-settled issues, like the risks and benefits of marijuana and whether local zoning laws should allow it to be sold on Main Street. If the legal availability of marijuana on Florence center somehow might endanger the public health or safety, or otherwise threaten harm to anyone’s rights, let the case be made.

Fortunately, there is a legal mechanism whereby legitimate concerns can be addressed, namely, in the Host Community Agreement, Step #2 for license applicants, defined in the statute as “an agreement with the host community setting forth the conditions to have a marijuana establishment…”

There is already on the books a plethora of local and state laws relating to the use of land and buildings. It would be beyond the province of the mayor, when she signs an agreement, to attempt to trump them, but this language invites her to impose on Euphorium reasonable conditions on any aspect of their proposed operation not otherwise governed. It would be unfair to Euphorium if those conditions were not evidence-based.

Over the years I have been asked to explain Northampton’s success as a small city. What is the “it” that makes Northampton an extraordinarily fine place to live? My answer is proud tolerance, as our rainbow-striped crosswalk announces. We were a hotbed of abolitionism, of women’s suffrage, resistance to the Vietnam war and nuclear energy, support for the ERA and immigrants’ rights — and, yes — we led the initiatives to transform the marijuana laws of Massachusetts.

Northampton has consistently been in the vanguard of social change, and benefited immensely, starting with the tons of interesting people drawn here from other places.

This is no time to shrink from our tolerance for evolving legal, social, cultural and economic realities, nor is this the venue to revisit the merits of the laws that codified those changes, most enacted only after long struggles in the courts, the legislatures and the streets. Instead, it is a time to embrace it.

Let me be the first Florentinian to welcome the Arundellos into the community so long as they adhere to the laws passed by the people and their state and local representatives. That’s how democracy works. I wish them well.

Dick Evans, a local attorney, chaired the 2016 legalization initiative campaign committee.