Regarding J.M. Sorrell’s Oct. 7 column, “The people of Israel live,” questioning, disputation, scholarship and dissent have been fundamental Jewish traditions since the rabbinic era began with the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE, or perhaps since Jacob wrestled with a divine being. We are commanded to read and observe closely, to think for ourselves, and to strive for our own interpretations of texts and events.

Telling people what to think isn’t just intellectually insulting; it runs counter to our most beloved Jewish values. And thus Sorrell’s latest column, printed on Oct. 7 no less, is wrong on multiple levels.

After Israel’s appalling failure to do its first and only job — keeping Jews safe — and its subsequent, insane campaign of violence and destruction visited (in our name and with our hardware) upon a civilian population, we owe ourselves an honest reading of the text. What will no longer cut it: regurgitating AIPAC talking points, conflating the Israeli state with the Jewish people, making common cause with apocalyptic lunatics and war criminals, weaponizing Jewish victimhood, or replaying the broken record of Zionist mythology.

Don’t tell us we aren’t seeing what we’re seeing.

In the words of the visionary 18th-century rabbi Nachman of Breslov: “Whoever has eyes, let him see; whoever has a heart, let him understand what is happening in the world.”

Luke Jaeger

Northampton