A simple AI search says typical concrete parking garages in New England should last 50 to 70 years if designed and maintained properly. Was, has the Northampton structure been maintained? Or just forgotten? And now we learn about $100,000 a year is spent on remedial work to prevent failure. That’s unacceptable

Are we accepting poorly designed, built city structures? The UMass garage is almost 20 years older and showing no such signs of wear or failure. The mayor just announced $11.6 million on a geothermal system for the high school to reduce carbon emissions. Geothermal is complicated and expensive to maintain, far more than a parking garage. How can we possibly expect to maintain it, and at what cost? Are they known? A bit ironic that we are attempting to sequester carbon, when a garage of concrete and steel, the most carbon-intensive polluters, is failing and must be torn down.

We have been told there are 1,600 available parking spaces downtown, including the garage and private parking. Two hundred and twenty, possibly more, will be lost if the garage is demolished. And Picture This reduces another 57? So we are really dependent on private lot owners making lots available to the city/public to cover this deficit. What if they don’t and keep lots for themselves, customers and tenants? Then there is of course, the new housing without parking, but obviously many of those residents may own cars, as will any visitors, even if idle most days. This plan or lack thereof is heading in the same direction of the E. John Gare Garage. Failure

Phil Nash

Florence