Amherst Town Hall
Amherst Town Hall Credit: Gazette File Photo

AMHERST — Amherst officials are putting off imposing either a ban or a moratorium on data centers, and establishing specific regulations for their development, until sometime in 2027.

The Planning Board and Town Council’s Community Resources Committee, at a joint hearing last Thursday, agreed to continue the discussion at 6:45 p.m. Jan. 6, in part to allow more time for determining the scope of any ban or moratorium.

With a proposed prohibition on data centers co-sponsored by nine of the 13 elected councilors, District 2 Councilor Amber Cano-Martin told the panels she would like to see an outright ban, observing that at an earlier meeting in October there appeared to be movement toward a moratorium instead.

“The idea of banning this is because we already know that this is not something we want in Amherst,” Cano-Martin said. “There’s not a question in our minds.”

Cano-Martin said the concern is the large consumption of electricity and water and the air and noise pollution generated, all for what she said is “Big Tech” pursuing generative AI. 

Amherst, she said, has no land or water for data centers, and that housing for people of all income levels is a priority.

“Why would we spend staff time, energy and money on looking into this when we have a moratorium, when we know we don’t want to have data centers to begin with?” Cano-Martin said.

Council President Mandi Jo Hanneke, though, said she wants to get a common definition of what is being banned, and is worried that a ban would not only prohibit hyperscale data centers, but smaller ones. A tiered system could be included in rules and regulations, similar to one adopted in Mansfield.

As written, a facility would be considered a data center “if its electrical load attributable to information-technology equipment and associated cooling or power-conditioning equipment exceeds 1 megawatt, regardless of any other use designation or classification.”

Planning Board member Angus McLeod said Mansfield officials spent several months on the tiers and banned any data centers above 2 megawatts.

“I would prefer to see us change a lot of the wording to be more carefully targeted in the bylaw we’re considering around data centers,” McLeod said.

At-Large Councilor Andy Churchill said a moratorium is effectively the same as a ban, but the moratorium would give time, perhaps a year or longer, to figure out how to do a permanent ban correctly and without risk of a lawsuit.

Cano-Martin said the urgency for the ban is that companies are coming into communities and cutting back-room arrangements. Amherst needs to make it clear now that a data center is not allowed, especially should a company buy Hampshire College for that purpose.

Several residents spoke, almost all in favor of a ban. 

Esther Azar of Henry Street said data centers go against all the desires and interests of people living in town, compromising the health and safety of the community.

“I can’t imagine people would want to move to Amherst knowing the health risks associated with a data center,” Azar said.

In addition to environmental costs, Angelica Bernal, a resident who also teaches at the University of Massachusetts, said that her students understand AI won’t benefit them.

“My students are already rejecting the use of AI,” Bernal said. “They understand it will displace large sectors, devalue their degrees and lead to new levels of unemployment.”

Scott Merzbach is a reporter covering local government and school news in Amherst and Hadley, as well as Hatfield, Leverett, Pelham and Shutesbury. He can be reached at smerzbach@gazettenet.com or 413-585-5253.