The question before the Holyoke City Council is about more than just whether it should allow Walmart to open in the Northampton Street development.
This is ultimately a decision about values and what kind of future the council wants to invest in. Across the country, communities have been sold the same promise: lower prices, more convenience and economic growth. Yet for years, studies have shown that when Walmart moved in, local businesses struggled, workers faced downward pressure on wages and taxpayers absorbed hidden costs. If the council does decide to move forward, it could have consequences on our community for years to come.
Let’s start with Walmart’s pricing tactics. Earlier this year, the company won multiple patents to use AI and electronic shelf labels to set prices. This would allow prices to update “dynamically and automatically” on the shelf based on how much customers are willing to pay. How will they know how much shoppers will pay? Because another patent would allow them to compile profiles of shoppers, with search histories, online shopping carts, in-store receipts and even GPS locations.
These practices of using data to set prices are known as surveillance pricing and dynamic pricing, but altogether, this is predatory pricing, plain and simple. Walmart is making these tactics a reality by rushing to install electronic shelf labels throughout all of its stores. Imagine the weatherman predicts a nor’easter, and then Walmart changes the price of milk, eggs, bread and toilet paper on the shelf while you’re shopping the aisles. Prices can change in the blink of an eye, and people are already seeing this in real time.
Holyoke residents do not need to be subjected to this rip-off machine, and neither do workers. Deployment of these technologies threatens the livelihoods of grocery workers across our state. If Walmart and other retailers push ahead with this technology, workers in Massachusetts will lose $125 million in wages and 3,200 people will lose their jobs, according to a September report by AFL-CIO Tech Institute.
The risks don’t stop inside the store. Even beyond questions about pricing and jobs, research shows what happens to communities when a Walmart store arrives. One study found that in the 10 years after a Walmart Supercenter opened in a community, the average local household lost 6% of annual income — that’s about $5,000 a year. Is that really what the Holyoke City Council wants?
Our union has long documented the awful treatment workers receive at the whims of Walmart. The Northampton Street development includes no guarantee that Walmart will hire locally or pay above-average wages. In 11 states, more than 16,000 Walmart employees rely on public assistance, a 55% increase since 2020, and in three states, Walmart is the employer whose workers most rely on government assistance, according to one study. Instead of paying workers well, Walmart leaves taxpayers with the bill.
Walmart’s costs can also spill into other public services. In 2016, it was estimated that Walmart had a violent crime every day in one of its stores, and many local police departments shared how Walmart often swamps them with calls. This is a potential major strain on public safety resources that are already stretched thin. The Holyoke Police Department has better things to do than respond to calls at Walmart over a mis-scanned item at the register. In one case in Mississippi, one of these calls heartbreakingly ended in tragedy.
Holyoke employers like Stop & Shop and Key Foods do things the right way, enabling 300 Holyoke union grocery workers to earn family-sustaining wages and benefits. Walmart’s presence will only squeeze these businesses and undercut them at every turn.
A 2013 report found that within 15 months of a Walmart opening, up to 14 nearby retail locations can close, compared to just three or four new openings. If Walmart succeeds at closing off its competitors, Holyoke residents will have no choice but to shop at the Walmart rip-off.
The Holyoke City Council must reverse course on the Northampton Street Walmart development and reevaluate what kind of businesses we want to bring into our city. They have the chance to choose a high-road employer for our community — they can’t waste it.
Jeff Jones is the president of UFCW Local 1459. He lives in Springfield.
