On Nov. 5, the City Council unanimously voted to adopt a single tax rate, meaning residential, business and industrial properties are taxed at the same rate, equally sharing the burden of taxation.
This is a decision — and a council vote — that must be taken every year. But the decision is not pro forma.
At the Oct. 15 council meeting, Northampton Principal Assessor Marc Dautreuil II offered a detailed and data-rich presentation explaining the differences between a split tax rate and a single tax rate, the context in which municipalities select one option over the other, and a well-reasoned assessment for why he, Mayor Gina-Louise Sciarra and the Board of Assessors recommended the council adopt a single tax rate.
Residents spoke and asked questions during a public hearing on the tax classification decision and councilors had an opportunity to ask questions of the principal assessor.
I was persuaded that the recommendation to adopt a single tax rate was the right one for our city.
The state Department of Revenue recommends that communities where commercial/industrial properties make up 30 percent or more of the tax base consider split rates, but when it’s lower than that, stick to a single rate. Northampton’s commercial/industrial base is half that at 15 percent.
Northampton is among 233 communities that adopted single tax rates. Another 113 municipalities have split rates, with commercial/industrial property owners taking on a larger burden; 16 communities have a split rate in which residential properties pay a higher percentage.
A community might adopt a split rate when major taxpaying businesses are large and expected to stay put, (think power plant, mall, casino.) Northampton’s businesses are smaller, there is more churn, and our industrial properties are not particularly large or numerous.
A split rate favoring residential property owners would increase costs to businesses, raising legitimate concerns that businesses would be reluctant to move into the city or encouraged to move out, negatively impacting our tax base and risking spikes in residential costs if the commercial base experiences a downturn.
These are the reasons the City Council for years has adopted a single tax rate: because it makes sound financial sense.
I believe there were misunderstandings and faulty assumptions in the Nov. 9 Gazette story about the vote [“Northampton City Council keeps single property tax rate amid debate over L3Harris“].
At-Large City Councilor Meg Robbins said the council should spend more time discussing the tax classification decision and better understand options that protect homeowners who can’t afford higher taxes.
Both Councilor Robbins and a resident during public comment said the city should tax larger businesses more heavily than smaller businesses.
The fact is, we can’t. The state allows communities to tax residential property at a different rate than commercial/industrial, but it can’t tax commercial/industrial properties at different rates from each other.
Councilor Robbins implies our vote was somehow rushed. We first discussed it Oct. 15, when Assessor Dautreuil gave a 20-minute presentation followed by 20 minutes of questions and comments from the council. We then had three weeks until our vote, during which we were free to engage in as much research as necessary to arrive at our decision.
At that Nov. 5 meeting, we also had time to discuss and clarify before we took a vote. There was no hurry, other than the fact that we did need to vote that night — because that is our job.
For homeowners who can’t afford the increase, the assessors’ page on the city website offers links to forms to apply for tax relief if they qualify. This was discussed at the meeting.
For the record, what would the savings be if the city split the rate?
The principal assessor’s powerpoint addressed that too: If Northampton adopted a split rate with the maximum shift from residential to commercial/industrial allowed by the state, the average single-family home valued at $580,692 would see an annual decrease in its tax of $743.
In that scenario, the average commercial property valued at $743,482 would see an increase of $5,144; the average industrial property valued at $982,979 would see an increase of $6,802.
In my mind, on balance, what an average homeowner might save when compared with how much our businesses (most rather small) would be burdened did not seem like a wise trade-off, given the longer-term risks.
A split tax rate is no magic bullet. More likely it would usher in unintended consequences that would hurt our city. But rest assured, the decision was made with ample information and ample discussion time to make the best choice for Northampton.
Laurie Loisel is the Ward 3 city councilor for Northampton.
