HADLEY — Lightning Hill is the name generations of Hadley residents have given to the peak of Breckenridge Road, where a gravel pit could soon become the location of a stand-alone battery energy storage system.

“It is incredibly prone to lightning strikes,” said Linda Hannum, of Sylvia Heights.

For residents who have organized to halt the placement of a 5-megawatt facility in the 5-acre site above Zatyrka Park, where there is a playground, gazebo and walking trails, the fact that lightning regularly splits trees and tears off bark makes the location above the town’s aquifer unsuitable for this project.

On Thursday, nearly 30 people went to the Hadley Senior Center dining room, joined by another dozen or more attending virtually, to appeal to the Board of Health to take a stand against the development.

They contend that the Board of Health could intervene after the Planning Board last month approved site plans, a solar project special permit and a business use in aquifer special permit for ZP Battery Devco’s 5-megawatt system. The meeting came two nights after the Conservation Commission voted 3-0 against the project. Commission members cautioned that they typically only weigh in on matters when wetlands are involved but still determined the project likely wasn’t appropriate for the neighborhood.

“We are asking for you to join the Conservation Commission in opposing this project outright,” Hannum said.

Planners had initially rejected the development in January 2025, concerned with potential impacts on the aquifer and public safety should there be a fire or leaks, before facing a lawsuit in Hampshire Superior Court in which the company argued the board’s decision was legally untenable and “unreasonable, arbitrary and capricious.”

The Lightning Hill nickname for the top of Breckenridge Road, along with the gravel pit remaining an active site with unstable material at its base, are among neighbors’ many objections to the development.

Residents gather at a meeting of the Hadley Board of Health to discuss ZP Battery Devco’s proposal to build a 5-megawatt battery storage system. Credit: SCOTT MERZBACH / Staff photo

Since the agenda only called for public comment on the project, the Board of Health made no decision and took no action on the request. Neither the developer nor the landowner, Karl’s Excavating, was present to rebut any of the information presented.

Hannum said she understands that the health board will likely have to prove there is a risk to the aquifer. Her hope is that the information residents provided, supplemented with photographic evidence from the site and pictures of a similar development that caught on fire and burned in Warwick, New York, will be sufficient.

Members of the group organizing opposition, though, said they understand this is only a starting point.

The aquifer is the big concern for Carol Soules of Sylvia Heights. Soules said the porous soil and fragile and unstable embankments should have necessitated a hydrogeologic study, which was not required for the proposal to proceed.

“I feel like there are risks to [the] health and safety of residents,” Soules said. “The developer should find a safer place.”

There are potential noise concerns, too. Donna Kurkul of Frallo Drive said residents below the gravel pit can already hear everything that happens there, and the battery noise will be excessive.

Gail Mengel of Sylvia Heights said that a catastrophe could happen, and it’s unclear if the town has the resources to handle an emergency, whether a fire or a leak.

Greg Owen of Breckenridge Road said the town should mitigate the threat and plan for the worst-case scenarios, adding that the best hazard prevention would be to prohibit such a development altogether.

Others suggested that the project would be more appropriate along Route 9, where there are already areas paved over and fewer residential homes.

Kristi Nelson of Sylvia Heights said that those concerned with the development are green energy advocates who understand the need to support solar and battery energy storage, but harming drinking water is not a good trade-off.

“We feel very strongly it should not be in this location,” Nelson said.

Scott Merzbach is a reporter covering local government and school news in Amherst and Hadley, as well as Hatfield, Leverett, Pelham and Shutesbury. He can be reached at smerzbach@gazettenet.com or 413-585-5253.