AMHERST — The Town Council agreed Monday to continue exploring a site for a new Department of Public Works headquarters in the northern part of Amherst near Puffer’s Pond.

While no decisions have been made on where the new 34,687-square-foot, $35 million building should be built, a favorable vote by the councilors at Monday’s meeting means that the DPW Building Committee can continue to look at the Ruxton gravel pit site at 531 Pulpit Hill Road.

It also allows Weston & Sampson consultants to do schematic designs for the building that would replace the current 18,833-square-foot building that uses a converted 1916 trolley barn.

The building committee, at its October meeting, indicated that it is leaning toward the town-owned site in North Amherst for the facility, even though the committee’s charge from Town Manager Paul Bockelman is to only look at the current 586 South Pleasant St. location. The Ruxton site had initially been viewed as a possible swing site or back-up site, but is now seen as a primary option.

Bockelman presented councilors information about how Ruxton could be a more economical site, and is slightly larger at 4 acres compared to 3.8 acres for the current site. Ruxton is 3.5 miles from town center, compared to the current site being 1.9 miles from town center.

Still, Bockelman describes Ruxton as “one that had certain advantages over the current site.”

“In essence it had more room, it allowed us to build a building without needing to relocate staff,” Bockelman said. “It also had a side benefit, if we chose to, to have a site for the fire station. So there were many good positives for this.”

J.P. Parnas, lead architect and project manager with Weston & Sampson, told the building committee that the design now has three working maintenance bays and a dedicated state inspection bay, reduced from six bays in an earlier 53,000-square-foot iteration. The latest design also removed one-third of the square footage from garage to lower the estimated budget.

Plans for the building, though, remain much smaller than a $68 million project from 10 years ago.

Bockelman said he is looking for the path of least resistance, after not moving forward with a site on South East Street that would have been provided by Amherst College. That location ran into neighborhood opposition. The town also dismissed acquiring properties on South Pleasant to expand the DPW site.

Should the move to North Amherst happen, it would free up the current DPW site for the South Amherst fire station, a new building that would replace the aging Central fire station downtown.

Earlier the edge of the former Hickory Ridge Golf Course on West Pomeroy Lane had been eyed for a new fire station, but Fire Chief Lindsay Stromgren determined that location is too far south.

Councilors expressed support for continuing the process at Ruxton, but also noted concerns with the site.

Most worries centered on traffic and distance, with the Ruxton site at the eastern end of a mostly gravel, narrow road, separated from nearby homes by railroad tracks. It is likely that DPW trucks would enter and exit from Leverett Road and via Cushman village.

District 3 Councilor George Ryan said the location is a major disadvantage.

“I am concerned about the issue of location, and traffic, particularly through Cushman. It would seem to be an enromous amount of traffic there,” Ryan said.

With the Cushamn Scott Children’s Center in Henry Street, there were questions about whether DPW trucks would be prohibited from passing by that location.

DPW Superintendent Guilford Mooring, at the building committee meeting in October, said that he would make it work, and there wouldn’t be delays in areas of town when plowing and sanding roads. Already High Point Drive in North Amherst, and Bay Road in South Amherst, are the most challenging places to get to. Mooring said he has worked in communities with much larger land masses than Amherst.

District 5 Councilor Ana Devlin Gauthier said constituents in South Amherst might be concerned that the DPW would be far away, but having a new fire station that can provide quicker reponse may be more important to residents.

“I definitely support looking at the Ruxton site, and I think, in fact, that would be my preference,” said District 2 Councilor Amber Cano-Martin, adding that it could allow both building projects to be done as quickly as possible.

“Having a spot that we could then have a designated space for a South Amherst fire station could be important,” said At-Large Councilor Andy Churchill.

District 5 Counciolor Sam MacLeod said he supports exploring Ruxton, but notes that it is a remote site and the roads may not have enough capacity.

One other issue at Ruxton is the need to provide either an on-site septic system or an extension of a municipal sewer line.

Scott Merzbach is a reporter covering local government and school news in Amherst and Hadley, as well as Hatfield, Leverett, Pelham and Shutesbury. He can be reached at smerzbach@gazettenet.com or 413-585-5253.