AMHERST — Weeks after a resident’s arrest on a strangulation charge, town officials are exploring changes to zoning or to a 1980s special permit to address concerns about Theta Chi, a fraternity suspended by UMass whose North Pleasant Street house is home to university students.

In a Nov. 2 letter, Shelly Perdomo-Ahmed, UMass vice chancellor for student affairs and campus life, outlined how the town could shut down the fraternity, saying it is out of compliance with zoning because it lacks a site plan and a management plan. In response, Town Council members on Monday asked Town Manager Paul Bockelman for options on how to handle the property at 496 N. Pleasant St.

Questions about Theta Chi’s presence have flared since an Oct. 23 incident in which a resident of the house allegedly put a woman, also a student, in a chokehold. Amherst police charged him with strangulation, a felony, and misdemeanor assault and battery. He pleaded not guilty at his arraignment in Eastern Hampshire District Court on Oct. 27.

“What I’m hearing is the council would like some guidance on what zoning changes might be able to be considered potentially at some future point,” Town Council President Mandi Jo Hanneke said.

“Once you get the information, there may be zoning changes the council may want to propose,” Bockelman said.

Theta Chi is suspended by UMass from Jan. 9, 2025, through May 31, 2028.

But Bockelman said that while UMass considers the fraternity no longer affiliated with the university, Theta Chi operates under a special permit issued in the 1980s and is still recognized by its national organization.

“They are operating under a special permit from the town that was legal at the time,” Bockelman said.

What is unclear is whether enrolled students living there are enough to constitute a relationship with UMass, and what property rights the building owner has.

Bockelman suggested the best way for UMass to act would be to file a complaint about the special permit with Building Commissioner Rob Morra. That would start a process for challenging the special permit and send it back to the Zoning Board of Appeals for discussion and action.

District 5 Councilor Ana Devlin Gauthier said it is absurd to argue over whether Theta Chi is related to UMass.

“I think that the university telling us that they do not claim them, it’s pretty clear to me,” Devlin Gauthier said.

District 4 Councilor Pam Rooney said the town has the ability to rezone districts, eliminating the fraternity and sorority districts that exist.

District 2 Councilor Lynn Griesemer noted that any decisions with respect to zoning may also affect other fraternity houses.

In fact, District 2 Councilor Amber Cano-Martin observed that Kappa Sigma, suspended since last spring, and Alpha Sigma Phi, suspended since 2021, are also not recognized or in good standing with UMass. Students live at both those homes, but neither has a site plan or a management plan.

Bockelman said that while Morra has determined that Theta Chi can legally operate under zoning, the town could take steps under the nuisance house bylaw. The house already has multiple violations, and fines of $300 could be assessed to residents and, in some cases, the property owner.

Town Council could also push UMass to use its student code of conduct to be more forceful with students, no matter where they live.

Bockelman said that he expects to respond formally to the university’s concerns soon.

District 4 Councilor Jennifer Taub said suspension seems to benefit residents, because they get to live in a group house, or boarding house, don’t have to comply with the town’s limit of four unrelated people living together, and are no longer under UMass’ oversight.

“Once their behavior is so egregious that they are suspended and are not recognized as part of the Greek system at UMass, but they are allowed to have their house, it’s almost a win-win situation for the fraternity,” Taub said.

Though the Town Council is discussing the matter, Hanneke said the burden shouldn’t fall entirely on the town. She said UMass should step up enforcement of its student code of conduct, noting there may be a way to create new violations for students who choose to live in unregistered fraternity and sorority houses.

“It shouldn’t all be found and be placed on the town to deal with this, and I think the university needs to step up even more than they have,” Hanneke said.

Scott Merzbach is a reporter covering local government and school news in Amherst and Hadley, as well as Hatfield, Leverett, Pelham and Shutesbury. He can be reached at smerzbach@gazettenet.com or 413-585-5253.