Johanna Neumann
Johanna E. Neumann Credit: FILE PHOTO

Data centers were a defining topic in the mid-term election, as well as local city council meetings here in the Pioneer Valley. My take: we should hit the brakes on large data center developments to make sure they don’t trash our air, water, nature, and a livable future for our kids. 

What are data centers?

Data centers are large buildings — many larger than hundreds of football fields put together — packed floor to ceiling with computer servers. These servers require cooling equipment to operate efficiently, which in turn requires enormous amounts of energy. Data centers never stop running.

“Hyperscale” data centers are particularly large and energy-intensive. For the purposes of this column, I will define hyperscale data centers as using more than 50 megawatts of power, consuming roughly the same amount of energy as all the homes in Amherst, Northampton and Holyoke combined. Large hyperscalers, such as one proposed for land in the town of Sutton, roughly 50 miles southeast of us, can use up to 20 times more. 

There are already more than 3,000 data centers in operation across the U.S., with at least 700 more proposed. The surge in new proposed data centers is fueled largely by the tech industry’s desire to get as much computing capacity online as fast as possible in their pursuit of artificial intelligence (AI). I’m not anti-AI. It could expand our frontiers of knowledge, develop breakthrough cures for diseases, and more. But greater computing capacity can also make our lives worse. Just think about  ‘AI slop’, cryptocurrency mining, and deep-fakes. 

We also need to consider the following and ask if the current uncontrolled rush to build data centers is worth it: 

Data centers are prolonging the lives of dirty power plants

Burning coal causes serious environmental and health problems. Worryingly, energy demand from data centers has already postponed the closures of fossil fuel generators at 15 power plants, many of which burn coal. Now, they’re scheduled to stay online, some as long as through 2065. 

Data centers are fueling a surge in new fossil fuel power plants

Natural gas consists mostly of methane, a potent global warming gas. Proposals for grid-connected natural gas power plants have nearly tripled since early 2023 and increased by nearly half in the last eight months alone. Anthropic, a leading AI company, just announced a deal for more than $3 billion in new gas plants to power its data centers. 

Data centers often come with dirty diesel generators

Because data centers need to run 24/7 year-round, they need reliable backup power. Many data centers are investing in polluting diesel generators on site for this purpose. Diesel exhaust has been linked to potentially fatal respiratory problems and is classified as a probable human carcinogen by the International Agency for Research on Cancer. 

Ramping up fossil fuel power generation to power data centers is a massive step in the wrong direction. That’s a key reason why we need to hit the brakes on large data centers. 

But it’s not the only one. Other environmental concerns that arise include water stress, noise pollution, and the creation of local heat islands. The demand would also increase pressure to extract resources and, after a few years of use, lead to a surge in electronic waste. And, many new data centers are being proposed in rural areas, so their development often means paving over farmland, forests or other natural areas. At a time when America is running short on nature, we shouldn’t pave over areas that provide space for native plants or wildlife without at least asking what it is in service to.

I am heartened that a number of states, including New York, have implemented moratoria on data centers. I hope you’ll join me in calling on Gov. Maura Healey to join her colleagues in other states and support a two-year moratorium on large data centers. We need to slow down, develop the policies and guardrails that will allow us to build the data centers we actually need, rather than the flood of data centers that market incentives and corporate shareholders want. Most of all, we need to do so in a way that doesn’t derail America’s transition to renewable energy.

We can realize the promise of AI without destroying our planet, ravaging natural areas, threatening our health and compromising our well-being in the process. But it requires a course correction, starting now.

Johanna Neumann of Amherst has spent the past two decades working to protect our air, water and open spaces, defend consumers in the marketplace and advance a more sustainable economy and democratic society. She can be reached at columnists@gazettenet.com.