Julie Esther Fisher Credit: CONTRIBUTED

“‘You’re a picture,’ Blass says. ‘Pretty as a – ’” 

— Julie Esther Fisher, “The Knowledge,” in “A Pearl is Just an Accident”

Eliza James has a scar. She has quite a few, actually. But let’s not get carried away. Let’s assume that the art restorer has one wound that doesn’t quite heal, that in fact is painted over — with her own expertly applied make-up, with a mother’s wound that she feels born to patch up. The central character in Julie Esther Fisher’s debut novel in short stories, “A Pearl is Just an Accident,” is at turns an adult who yields to the vicious caress of a mini-dress after long days in the gallery; a child whose mother always wants to leave, so is never here; an adolescent whose father cuts deeply; and a tween who invents limericks and lies so her sister will be spared the same sorrow.

Fisher, a Hawley resident who grew up in London, where the majority of the novel’s 15 stories are set, is an award-winning fiction writer and a luminous poet who has lived with the James family — in her mind, in her spirit — for the past 30 years. Earlier in her career, some of them made it to the page, but it took decades for Fisher to understand their role in her life. The novel is actually Fisher’s masterpiece. But it got banged up pretty badly when she tried to restrain its whimsy, its musicality, for her own good, according to several editors. What if it were true, she asked herself, that after all these years, her writing wasn’t readable?

Let’s imagine that Fisher grew up in a musical household. That music, in fact, was her first language, the language of her mother, a classical concert pianist, and her father, a jazz pianist. Imagine that she, too, learned the joys of reading aloud, the way words are made of sounds and those sounds can sing depending on the composer’s ear.

Imagine not trusting your own ear. 

Imagine silence.

“It took me all those years to say, ‘I’m going to be on my side,’” Fisher said. “I’m going to write what I want, learn as much craft as I can and not try to be something I’m not.”

Credit: CONTRIBUTED

One day, long after moving to the States, after that last bid for her to edit away her stories’ poetry, she began writing in the way she has always written — by hand. She starts at the top of the page and, as though in a trance, doesn’t stop her pen until all her words have been released. “It produces a kind of amnesia where I can have very little sense of what I wrote,” she said of her process. “I go back with a pencil and underline odd lines that seem to hold some crackle for me, and I can feel it in my body, a hum of recognition.”

Her freewriting led her back into “the old magic of London” and the arms of the James family.

“It felt sort of like going home,” she said.

After writing two short stories that were published immediately, Fisher knew that the essence of her book had always been her fictional family, who were counting on her to restore her novel.

In the opening story, “Pentimento,” Eliza, commissioned to restore a painting of a 17th-century Dutch nobleman, recalls one of her mentor’s lessons about the difference between “what might have been” and what was:

“Do you see … how, just beyond it, what previously appeared to the naked eye as one big area of paint can now be seen to be in two distinct layers, one clearly laid down on top of the other?”

Or, as she writes in “À la façon de Venise”: “Somewhere beneath the white lay all these colors.” 

In “A Pearl is Just an Accident” (Silent Clamor Press, 358 pages, $19.99) all the characters are rendered with grace at Fisher’s pace. In a particularly touching story near the end of the book, “Over the Bodies,” adult Eliza returns to the woods where her father scarred her before her 16th birthday. But on this journey into memory and possibility — what was, what might have been — she is accompanied by the nobleman in the painting she has been commissioned to restore. At the beginning of the book, Eliza discovers he has a secret scar under a layer of paint that the original artist applied to shine a light on his majesty, unmarred by what only looks grotesque.

In “Over the Bodies,” his scar is covered up, invisible, while Eliza’s is out in the open.

“What happened next? ask his eyes, their dusky melancholy too laden for me not to understand,” Fisher writes. “He means with my story.”

Fisher will read from “A Pearl is Just an Accident” on Nov. 21 at Forbes Library’s Gallery of Readers. To learn more and buy the book, visit julieestherfisher.com. Melissa Karen Sances can be reached at melissaksances@gmail.com.