EASTHAMPTON — Can Williston afford it? A growing group of residents thinks so, and they’re pushing the tax-exempt private school to make direct payments to the city.

The Williston Can Afford It campaign is gaining momentum as Williston Northampton School has twice turned down a payment-in-lieu-of-taxes (PILOT) proposal from Mayor Salem Derby, most recently last week. Derby said another meeting is planned for early December to discuss other ways the school could support the city.

Williston, founded in 1841, is a private college-prep school with 434 students in grades 7 through 12. As a nonprofit, the boarding school owns more than 30 tax-exempt academic, residential and recreational properties throughout the city, with a main campus on Park Street.

Kelley Hutchins, left, Jen Sandler, middle, and Violet McDonald, members of Williston Can Afford It campaign, hand out flyers as people pass by on Election Day at Easthampton High School. CAROL LOLLIS / Staff Photo

If it weren’t exempt, Williston would owe roughly $800,000 or more a year in property taxes, according to a city estimate and a Gazette review of property values. While exempt from property taxes, Williston pays other costs associated with its properties, such as utilities.

Over the summer, a small group of residents launched the campaign, urging Williston to enter a PILOT agreement with the city to provide direct financial support and, in their words, pay its “fair share.”

“(During) the override some of us met and were talking about other ways to get revenue for the city instead of just personal property taxes, and we started looking into PILOT agreements,” said Celia Oyler, a member of the campaign.

As increases loom from the $6.9 million property tax override voters approved in June, and as the city grapples with budget constraints, the campaign has drawn growing support since going public in recent weeks, handing out flyers throughout the city and establishing an online presence. The group has roughly seven core members, but attracted more than 20 at a recent meeting and has an email list of more than 100.

“We really care about this town and we think that everybody who lives here should pay their fair share, and that Williston should to,” member Jen Sandler said at a recent campaign meeting.

Mayor’s proposal

Williston officials and Derby began discussing a PILOT in March after the mayor proposed what he called “a strategic partnership” between the two as he looked for creative sources of funding.

Derby’s proposal would have had Williston contribute $400,000 to Easthampton over three years. Williston initially declined. In an email to the Gazette in April, Ann Hallock, director of communications, said the school was in the midst of a budget cycle and preparing to hire a new chief financial officer, but would be open to future conversations.

Last week, Derby met with Donna Falcetti, Williston’s new CFO, and Eric Yates, its chief advancement officer. Derby said they had a “candid discussion,” in which Williston again declined a PILOT agreement.

According to Derby, Falcetti said the school is in debt because of construction of a new $27 million academic center, the first academic building Williston has built in more than 50 years.

“If we can’t do the strategic partnership that I presented to them, they balked at that, then I would like to see something significantly meaningful, whether it’s public safety support or a capital project,” Derby said. “Their success depends on our success and that’s really what I’m trying to put forward … This needs to be a symbiotic relationship and that’s what we’re working towards.”

Williston position

Williston officials declined a request for an interview with Falcetti. In a phone interview, Hallock spoke on Falcetti’s behalf, saying the school is not currently in a position to accept a PILOT agreement.

“We’re embarking on the largest, most expensive capital project the school has ever done, which includes borrowing $10 million,” Hallock said about the academic center. “We really want to support the city of Easthampton, but we don’t want to make promises we can’t keep.”

Asked about the debt Derby mentioned, Hallock declined to comment. She said she has heard of the Williston Can Afford It campaign, but the school has not been contacted by it directly.

Williston released a report on Oct. 30 detailing ways it has supported Easthampton. The report says the school is one of the city’s largest employers, with 182 staff members, 75 of whom live on campus, and says those employees contribute substantially to the local economy.

Williston’s residential properties, which house faculty and staff, are of particular interest to the campaign because they are off the tax rolls, members said.

The report also highlights services the school provides, including snowplowing a portion of the Manhan Rail Trail each year, offering discounted access to athletic facilities for local sports teams and residents, and in-kind donations and partnerships with local businesses and nonprofits. Williston has historically given grants to the city as well.

Sandler said those efforts are welcome, but they do not provide direct support to Easthampton schools, public safety, public works and other departments.

“I make donations, I support local businesses,” Sandler said. “It doesn’t help our public schools … it doesn’t help our fire department.”

Tax filings show Williston had $130 million in total assets in 2025, with $44.3 million in revenue and $42 million in expenses. The school’s endowment reached $67 million, a $7 million increase from the year before after a large fundraising push.

Tuition for boarding students this year, before financial aid, is $82,700. Of Williston’s 434 students, 274 board.

The campaign has gathered information about Williston’s finances from public records and communications with city officials, including Derby and Superintendent Michelle Balch.

According to Derby’s proposal to Williston, the school would owe about $867,000 a year in property taxes based on the fiscal 2025 tax rate. A Gazette review of Williston’s property values produced slightly different figures: about $803,000 for fiscal 2025 and $850,000 for fiscal 2026. The amount shifts each year with the tax rate and property valuations.

Residents push for more

Alison Curphey, a member of the citizen campaign, said the override vote and resulting property tax increase are a hit for many residents. The override will increase resident property tax bills by an average of $1,200 a year, an increase that will be reflected on quarter three tax bills, planned to be mailed in late December and early January. 

“While I support nonprofit status of educational institutions, I do think that the number of properties that Williston has removed from the tax rolls is significant, and they should do something more consistently, annually and transparently,” Curphey said.

Members have been canvassing throughout the city and were especially active on Election Day, handing out pamphlets about their mission. Sandler said support has come from all demographics: residents for and against the override, Democrats and Republicans, young and old.

Kelley Hutchins and Jen Sandler, members of Williston Can Afford It, talk about strategies when handing out flyers as people pass by on Election Day at Easthampton High School. CAROL LOLLIS / Staff Photo

“This is a unifying campaign and this can bring the town together, to support our town, no matter who we are,” Sandler said.

Resident Melissa Weinberger joined the effort after speaking with members outside the polls on Election Day. Her child attends Easthampton Public Schools, which had to cut five educators this year because of the city’s budget deficit, even with override money, Balch previously told the Gazette.

“I was going to vote and I was handed a little piece of paper. I looked at and I said, ‘Absolutely,'” Weinberger said in an interview with the Gazette.

Despite Williston’s latest rejection, the campaign plans to hold a community forum to hear more residents’ ideas about how the city could collaborate with the school.

“I feel a sense of responsibility to find ways to ease the burden on people in town who are now having to pay more property taxes (from the override), and the fact is, Williston can afford it,” member Elyse Langer said.

Sam Ferland is a reporter covering Easthampton, Southampton and Westhampton. An Easthampton native, Ferland is dedicated to sharing the stories, perspectives and news from his hometown beat. A Wheaton...