The South Hadley Fire District 1 station at 144 Newton St. (Rt. 116). Photographed on April 13, 2021.
The South Hadley Fire District 1 station at 144 Newton St. (Rt. 116). Photographed on April 13, 2021. Credit: —STAFF PHOTO/KEVIN GUTTING

SOUTH HADLEY — A new group formed in the wake of the town’s failed Proposition 2½ override last spring to study merging the fire and water districts has found making such a move would save an estimated minimum of $812,400 annually.

The District Merger Study Group presented its findings to the water commissioners for Fire Districts 1 and 2 on Monday night. Most of the savings would come through staff consolidation and shared equipment. The operating and capital costs for water services would decrease by a yearly minimum of $593,000, while fire services could save between $218,900 and $344,800, depending on staffing levels.

South Hadley’s two fire districts operate as separate quasi-municipal governments serving different sections of town. Each district includes a Fire Department and Water Department. District 1 encompasses the two-thirds of town near South Hadley Falls, while District 2 covers Mount Holyoke and the Village Commons areas. The merger proposal would examine combining those services under a single district structure.

This marks the fifth time South Hadley’s district governments have studied the impacts of a merger. Outside consultants assisted with merger studies in 1983, 1990, 2003 and 2024. While some studies concluded that a merger would significantly improve services and efficiency, others recommended maintaining the existing structure.

At Monday’s meeting, water commissioners and staff were eager to conclude the 40-year-long conversation over merging District 1 and 2 for both the cost savings and potential to boost service efficiency.

“I mean enough’s enough. Like let’s just figure this thing out,” said Dan Luis, chair of the District 2 Board of Water Commissioners. “We see the savings that’s on the board. How can we all not come together and see that savings?”

The citizen-led District Merger Study Group began meeting in May after residents rejected $9 million and $11 million overrides. In 2024, the town backed a nonbinding ballot question to merge the districts. Both voting outcomes motivated citizens to investigate a consolidation plan, group member Christine Phillips said.

“We’ve had some really good, spirited, open, transparent conversations,” Phillips said.

The group met roughly every three weeks, and held additional meetings within four subcommittees: fire operations, water operations, finance and communications. They started with a baseline of 13 water department full-time employees across the two districts and a combined fiscal 2027 budget of $4.11 million. Similarly, both fire departments had a combined 32 staff funded through an $8.21 million budget.

Their analysis resulted in two alternative models for a water district and two ideas for fire service organization.

The proposed water district would have 10 full-time staff. The first organization would include a water superintendent, a foreman, two office staff and six water operators. The second option swaps two of the water operators for an additional foreman and an assistant superintendent.

The first scenario would have an estimated budget of $3.42 million, saving roughly $682,200 a year, while the other model is estimated to cost $3.51 million a year, or a savings of $593,500.

Fire services would have either 32 or 36 full-time staff in the new model presented. There would be four companies each with a captain, lieutenant and a minimum of five firefighters. The groups would be overseen by a fire chief and a deputy fire chief and supported by an administrative assistant.

With 32 employees, an estimated merged budget of $7.87 million is roughly $344,800 lower than the current combined budgets. A 36-person department would require around $8 million to support, saving an estimated $218,900. The savings would likely come from having a single fire chief and deputy fire chief, the report found.

District 2 Fire Chief Ryan Moore told the Gazette in a phone call after the meeting that a department with a staff of 32 would leave both stations — Fire District 1’s station is located at 144 Newton St. and Fire District 2’s station is at 20 Woodbridge St. — short as the districts are currently staffed at minimum levels. He said District 2 relies on an on-call EMT to fully staff the ambulance, and moving a full-time member from District 1 to the other fire station would leave them short.

Moore said the change for him is not about cost-savings. “It has to be a better department as one than two, that would be a reason to merge,” he said.

The analysis also included an expanded staff model of 38 employees, similar to the Easthampton Fire Department. This scenario would cost an additional $89,400 a year to current combined budgets.

Phillips emphasized that these numbers are all estimates based on preliminary findings. The actual operational savings will not be seen overnight, and the merger itself is a long legal and logistical path.

“We absolutely know that in the longer term, it will already take really good services and make them even better,” Phillips said. “You won’t have duplication of efforts. You won’t have duplication of equipment. The cost savings will come. It will just take time.”

While a merger would likely save money on operational costs, residents might not see this immediately reflected in their water bills, officials said. District 1 currently has a lower water rate compared to District 2. If the rates were blended together, the residents of District 1 would need to pay more, and households in District 2 would pay less, they said.

Pauline McClaflin, a District 1 water commissioner, said she’s heard residents make this point to argue against a district merger.

“If we combine, there has to be some give-and-take,” she said.

District 1 Water Superintendent Jeff Cyr, who also chairs the Select Board, noted a couple of untapped savings found in the minor details. Right now, District 1 gets its water from the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority, while District 2 uses groundwater. Under one system, more homes could get onto well water, which decreases the rate paid to MWRA.

Cyr also noted that most of the maintenance work for the water systems is done in-house, so even a fraction of the District Merger Study Group’s savings could improve overall service.

“(I am) not shooting for the stars for [$680,000], but again, based on capital plans that we currently have, you can take that and stretch it really fast,” Cyr said.

The water commissioners encouraged the citizen group to keep pursuing a merger. Phillips said the group will eventually need a consultant to consolidate the two governments, manage any union negotiations and send a plan to the attorney general’s office for approval.

“I think the naysayers are quickly dropping off the side,” retired District 2 Fire Chief David Keefe said. “I’m getting the read from the room that people want us to keep looking at this, and we’ll get past any of the obstacles.”

The District Merger Study Group will meet next on Dec. 2 in the South Hadley Library at 4:30 p.m. The meeting is open to the public.

Emilee Klein covers the people and local governments of Belchertown, South Hadley and Granby for the Daily Hampshire Gazette. When she’s not reporting on the three towns, Klein delves into the Pioneer...