In Worthington and Petersham, solar fears have found an outside megaphone.
Each town hosts controversy over proposed solar facilities. Each offers a classic example of opponents announcing “sky-is-falling” predictions about environmental and health impacts from solar arrays and battery storage. And each local opposition campaign has benefited from amplification by a Massachusetts right-wing advocacy network with ties to powerful national champions of fossil fuel dependence.
In these small, heavily forested communities, the proposed solar projects would occupy less than one percent of town acreage while increasing the towns’ solar generation by approximately 500% to match the combined electricity consumption of town government, business and residences, according to analysis by the Western Massachusetts Clean Energy Network. Opponents deploy a shifting portfolio of claims, from the mundane — “The solar farm will be hideous and change our town’s character” — to the alarming — “Our town will become another Love Canal,” or, “The aquifer will be ruined.”
Those last warnings appear in a recent YouTube video filmed in Worthington by the Fiscal Alliance Foundation. Linking these claims is the misleading portrayal of solar arrays and battery energy storage systems as “industrial” development.
Industrial? Surely those who attach this term to solar arrays would concede it describes oil rigs, tankers and refineries, fracking wells, pipelines and the power plants that spew CO2 and other pollutants. How do the impacts of those facilities compare with solar panels and battery containers? Do solar farms belch air pollutants? Generate wastewater requiring costly treatment? Consume enormous quantities of fuel? Leave behind contaminated soil and water? Solar and BESS projects warrant scientific scrutiny in their siting, fire safety and environmental risks. But equating their routine impacts with those of fossil fuel infrastructure is a distortion, not an analysis.
Ironically, these self-described guardians of the local environment have found unlikely allies in the Fiscal Alliance network, which includes the Fiscal Alliance Foundation and the Massachusetts Fiscal Alliance, organizations that share a policy director and overlapping leadership and work alongside national think tanks aligned with fossil fuel interests.
The foundation recently published the Worthington video as well as a Petersham-focused op-ed in the Worcester Telegram & Gazette. But who are these anti-solar advocates anyway? They portray themselves as ordinary conservatives fighting big government and defending the average taxpayer. Yet their advocacy also advances policies closely aligned with the interests of the national fossil fuel industry.
In an Aug. 2, 2026, Worcester Telegram & Gazette op-ed, the foundation’s policy director, Laurie Belsito, wrote that Petersham’s “forests are not vacant land waiting for development. They are living infrastructure that stores carbon, filters drinking water, supports wildlife […] The land would be effectively sterilized by pointless industrial development.”
Did she mention her five years in the Washington government relations department of the Heritage Foundation? Heritage later led Project 2025, whose blueprint called for rolling back federal programs promoting a transition from fossil fuels and reconsidering the Environmental Protection Agency’s 2009 greenhouse gas endangerment finding, a foundation of federal climate regulation.
These are not merely old employment connections. In April 2020, representing the Massachusetts Fiscal Alliance, Belsito co-signed a letter supporting the Trump administration’s SAFE Vehicles Rule, which weakened federal fuel-economy standards; Heritage Action for America also signed. In August 2024, again representing MFA, she co-signed a letter urging Congress to repeal the Inflation Reduction Act’s clean-energy subsidies, alongside Heritage Action.
The foundation also regularly features analysis by Lisa Linowes, a former Texas Public Policy Foundation (TPPF) senior fellow who authored its 2018 reports criticizing wind-energy subsidies and siting impacts. TPPF’s board includes multiple oil-and-gas business executives. The web of relationships is too extensive to map here. But the question is not whether conservatives may advocate their views; of course they may. It is whether local residents are getting the full picture of the national agenda accompanying this supposed defense of their communities.
All political viewpoints deserve to be heard, debated and challenged. They do not deserve immunity when advocates spread misleading claims or inflame baseless fears. Nor should an organization be permitted to wrap itself in the mantle of populism, public safety and environmental conservation without scrutiny of whose interests its advocacy serves.
Massachusetts towns deserve honest assessments of solar and battery projects, not scare stories that prolong our dependence on fossil fuels while the costs of climate change mount.
John Pepi, of Easthampton, Prof. Juniper Katz, of Leverett, and Bruce and Rachel Scherer, of Orange, contribute to the Western Massachusetts Clean Energy Network.
