The doors of Porto, missing mezuzot and depicting the cross, embody the antisemitism that is built into the Zionist project.
In 1492, after Christian forces conquered the Muslim-ruled Emirate of Granada in the southern Iberian Peninsula and colonialism emerged on the world stage, Jews who did not convert to Catholicism were expelled from Spain. My Jewish family was kicked out of the newly formed Christian world and welcomed once again by the Muslim world. We moved to Aleppo, Syria, and were welcomed, accepted and cared for by the Arab world, as we had been for centuries. My family lived in the Al Shams region, which included Syria, Lebanon, Jordan and Palestine, for 400 years.
It is true that Jews lived in that region of the world. What is a fallacy, though, is that the State of Israel is a continuation of that legacy.
Today’s state stole that from us, creating the conditions that gave Jews power over another people when Arab Jews used to be neighbors with their Muslim and Christian community members.
The irony of Owen Zaret’s Nov. 3 guest column [“From Porto’s doorways to Easthampton’s City Hall“] is that Portugal and Spain began the colonialism that led to the creation of what is today identified as “the Jewish State.” My Jewish family, like many others, lived integrated into that Arab world, and when the British and French colonized the region, they brought with them the divide-and-conquer tactics that they used for centuries in Europe to keep their power.
The divide-and-conquer tactics offered Jews positions of power overseeing the financial power that lined the pockets of royalty so that Jews became the face of power. Just like the French gave Jews citizenship that was refused to Muslims in Algeria, so too did the British give Jews power in Palestine that was refused to the Muslim population.
This is a foundational piece of colonial rule: offer privilege to a scapegoat to divide and conquer. Align Jews with the powerful, pretend they are accepted, so that the masses can turn against them, and when those in power feel threatened, encourage scapegoating.
Offer the Jews that they pretended to welcome into French society, up for the Nazis.
Israel as a “Jewish” state is no different, using Jews as the face of power to line the pockets of the wealthy and keep the powerful in power. Zaret is correct that antisemitism is a problem; however, Easthampton’s divestment is its solution.
Allowing the “Jewish state” to be supported by American taxpayer dollars is a recipe for Jewish scapegoating that allows the powerful to name Jews as the problem while denying that Israel is actually just another piece of the Western colonial project to maintain Western power in the region.
Rabbi Esther Azar lives in Amherst.
