The 14th Amendment to the Constitution requires that the census count everyone in America. President Donald Trump wants to decide who is counted and who is not counted.
The U.S. Department of Commerce has proposed rule changes to the 2030 census that will exclude millions of Americans. It’s a consequential piece of the white nationalist agenda, along with the president’s voter-suppression efforts, his aggressive deportation policies and his order to remove information about slavery, Native American history and the contributions of women in our national parks and museums.
The Census Bureau is currently responsible for counting everyone living in America, regardless of citizenship or immigration status. The new rule would remove questions about race, ethnicity and sexual orientation, and it would prevent identification of special needs groups who now receive benefits. It would exclude non-citizens who aren’t permanent residents, including undocumented immigrants and refugees.
The new rule would officially disappear millions of people from the national count. If these ‘ghost’ Americans don’t exist on paper, the federal government will claim no obligation to send federal money to states for medical, social and educational services for the uncounted. The states will be left with sole responsibility to provide for every one of their residents.
Use of inaccurate and unreliable census data will drastically change our legislative system. It will be used to alter the number of state legislators, the size of voting districts and the number of representatives each state sends to Congress.
Undercounting large blocks of Massachusetts residents, including Black and brown citizens, international students, H-1B visa holders, refugees, asylum seekers and undocumented people, who collectively make up a very significant proportion of the population of Massachusetts, will lead to a huge loss of federal funds. Data will disappear, and when information that shines a light on economic inequalities vanishes, it’s easier for the federal government to deny our affordability crisis.
The Massachusetts economy will be devastated. The Project on Government Oversight reported that in FY 2023 the federal money sent to the Commonwealth of Massachusetts included $45.92 billion for Medicaid and Medicare; $6.72 billion for health spending excluding Medicaid and Medicare; $2.58 billion for infrastructure, including roads, energy production and water treatment; $1.08 billion for economic development; and $4.45 billion for housing. In addition, the state received $2.7 billion to support primary and secondary education. Following the dismantling of the Department of Education in 2026 and withdrawal of federal funds, many of our public school systems were forced to cut staff and reduce their services. Even larger education cuts are planned for fiscal year 2027.
Serious impacts on our healthcare system will occur in two ways: by curtailing medical research and by reducing Medicare and Medicaid. The Federation of American Scientists raised a red flag in September 2026, stating that the lack of quality race and ethnicity data will create “dire public health consequences,” consequences seen especially in Massachusetts, which is a national leader in public health research. “Lack of data narrows our visibility into who is getting sick, who is dying and whether the people who need help are getting it.” They wrote: “Health data depend on the census in a critical way.”
With the next wave of impacts from the “One Big Beautiful Bill” scheduled to hit our nation in January 2027, we will see huge premium increases and a continuation of people falling off of Medicaid rolls from the expanded qualification red tape. There will be entire segments of the Massachusetts population who can no longer afford health coverage or will lose their Medicaid. Our hospitals legally cannot turn anyone away from receiving lifesaving emergency care services, and rightfully so. Many of these newly uninsured will be part of the population that will not be counted in the census if the proposed changes are passed. The result will be a devastating blow to our state’s economy as we struggle to cover the cost of huge jumps in uninsured emergency healthcare with reduced federal funds.
In Massachusetts, millions, perhaps billions, of dollars would be lost from emergency preparedness and disaster response, for example, for our coastal cities which are experiencing increasingly extreme storms. The current administration is cutting back on FEMA benefits, placing on the states the burden of recovery from natural disasters.
Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick held a brief comment period, which ended Nov. 2, for the proposed rule changes to the 2030 census. But our time for action is not over. We must demand that the new Congress include census protection in their agenda to make America affordable again and provide equal opportunities to every American.
Nancy Polan and Laura Brooks are members of the Northampton Area League of Women Voters.
