NORTHAMPTON — The E.J. Gare Parking Garage, which the city is considering demolishing and replacing because of a degenerative structural condition known as “concrete cancer,” needs more repairs and more space closures than expected, Mayor Gina-Louise Sciarra said Thursday night.
Sciarra told the City Council that the garage, which already costs the city roughly $9,000 a month to maintain, needs additional work before winter.
She said Rob Marsoli, vice president and director of engineering with Hoffmann Architects, the firm the city hired to study the garage, identified several roof beams that need additional structural support ahead of winter freeze-thaw cycles and possible snow accumulation.
“These supports will extend from the upper levels down to the ground,” Sciarra said. “Hoffmann also recommended closing several additional parking spaces on level three and repairing a joint on level two to prevent further water infiltration.”
The city’s Central Services Department has requested pricing and an installation schedule for the additional shoring posts, Sciarra said.
The top two of the garage’s five levels have been closed since March, when the city hired Hoffmann to conduct a thorough examination of the structure. Hoffmann completed its report in July, and Sciarra presented the findings to the council Oct. 15.
The partial closure cut the garage’s capacity from 430 spaces to 220, and revenue has dropped sharply since March. The new closures will reduce capacity to 157 spaces, 150 of which are not reserved for accessible parking or electric vehicle charging.
At the Oct. 15 meeting, Central Services and Hoffmann presented options for the garage’s future ranging from partial or full repair to demolition and replacement. Marsoli described the garage as being in “severe disrepair,” pointing to slides that showed significant spalling, structural corrosion and alkali-silica reaction, a condition he called self-perpetuating.
Though the engineers recommended demolition and replacement as the best long-term investment, Sciarra said Thursday the city is consulting other experts for a second opinion.
“The engineer also responded to recent public suggestions that the garage could be repaired and preserved potentially with new construction above it. Marsoli’s recommendation remains that replacement is the best mid- to long-term investment,” Sciarra said. “Even so, the city is doing due diligence and exploring options with Desman [Parking Consultants], which is a highly regarded parking consultant and engineering firm.”
Sciarra said Desman has reviewed Hoffmann’s report and analysis, and the city is weighing the cost and timeline of seeking an independent second opinion.
The city will also test a free shuttle service Saturday during Bag Day, the shopping tradition in which customers who carry a reusable bag get discounts at local retailers. The garage’s fate will also depend on an updated downtown parking study, Sciarra said.
“The study will examine parking demand, peak usage, access and the number of spaces downtown we will need in the future; those findings will help us evaluate options that could include service parking, a replacement garage, or redevelopment that incorporates public parking,” Sciarra said. “We are working closely with Sen. [Jo] Comerford and Rep. {Lindsay] Sabadosa to keep them informed about the city’s process and to identify opportunities for state support as the project moves forward.”
The garage typically accounts for about a quarter of the city’s annual parking revenue. When the council approved the fiscal 2027 budget in June, the city projected $1.75 million in parking revenue, a 15% increase over fiscal 2026. Finance Director Charlene Nardi said the city likely won’t meet that projection.
“[The garage] is only a portion of our parking revenue, not all of it. So, it looks like we are not going to make our revenue projections,” Nardi previously told the Gazette. “We will be discussing how we’re going to make that up, whether it be in parking or in some other fashion — we’ll figure out how we will handle the loss.”
