In his book on Syria, John McHugo says the politics of Israel factors in to the difficulty we face over Syria. I believes these politics also favor hardliners in Iran, because the Palestinians’ plight appears very unjust. 

I wonder if the unfairness of U.S. unconditional support for the Israeli government precludes our government from being an honest broker for peace in the Middle East. 

Bearing my concerns, I attended a showing of the film, “The Occupation of the American Mind: Israel’s Public Relations War in the United States.”  One of the filmmakers, Sut Jhally, spoke and mentioned that his field of study is public relations and propaganda.

The film points out that Israeli officials view propaganda as a good thing. There may even be an Israeli cabinet minister in charge of fighting a media war on behalf of Israel. 

We might see this media war in the Gazette’s opinion page. In a 2009 blueprint for winning a media war on behalf of Israel, Dr. Frank Luntz suggested pointing to the excesses of the Hamas charter. Is it a coincidence that the Hamas charter has been called out on the Gazette’s opinion page?

The film asserts that said charter has been effectively abandoned by Hamas, and points to the Likud Party’s Original Party Platform, which is politically extreme and may well guide Israeli policy. 

A word on the Nazi genocide of Jews: It is an extremely serious fact of history. Using it to justify every policy of Israel risks trivializing that history, so that people become inured to its pain and the lessons it has to teach. 

The film referenced here is somewhat long, and demonstrates its points so many times that the viewer may protest, “all right, I get it already!”

That the presentation is thorough should not detract from the importance of the points being made. The film can be found at the website, occupationmovie.com. 

Mary Hall

South Hadley