President Donald Trump speaks at a campaign rally in Huntsville, Ala., on Sept. 22. Trump says he wants Democratic lawmakers to sign on to a Republican-crafted tax overhaul plan.
President Donald Trump speaks at a campaign rally in Huntsville, Ala., on Sept. 22. Trump says he wants Democratic lawmakers to sign on to a Republican-crafted tax overhaul plan. Credit: AP FILE PHOTO

It’s been another head-spinning week in Washington, D.C., as Republican senators lambasted the Republican president who carried on a multi-day fight with a grieving African-American Gold Star widow.

Earlier, two former presidents condemned the current White House occupant without ever mentioning his name. We are still talking about emails and Russians almost a year after Donald Trump was elected president.

But that didn’t stop Trump, House Speaker Paul Ryan and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell from moving forward with the new Republican agenda. Ronald Reagan’s ghost makes an appearance at every Republican convention, but the Republicans in Washington today honor him in name only.

While Reagan Republicans at least paid lip service to the idea of a balanced budget, the Trump Republicans barely bring up the budget deficit. They tout Reagan’s tax-cutting but ignore the rest of his legacy.

Trump tweeted early Wednesday morning that he is “Working hard on the biggest tax cut in U.S. history. Great support from so many sides. Big winners will be the middle class, business & JOBS.”

His daughter Ivanka tweeted, “Working families need #TaxReform & the time is now. This Administration is committed to ensuring all Americans can thrive in our economy.” And this came from press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders: “A vote against tax cuts is a vote against better jobs, higher wages & greater opportunity for the forgotten men & women of this country.”

I have been trying to understand the economic theory behind these tweets. I know that I may be overthinking this, but it seems important to try since these people are running the country. We already know that if it’s Trump’s proposal, he will automatically say that it is the biggest tax cut in history.

After a deep analysis of Trump tweets and Republican talking points, this seems to be the way they think it will work. The top 1 percent would see an average $129,030 tax cut and the top 0.1 percent would save an average of $722,510 The middle quintile would save an average of $660 per family. Meanwhile, the bottom brackets will get an average of $50 per family.

The estate tax would be eliminated, benefiting the wealthiest 0.2 percent of estates. Currently, $5.49 million of a person’s wealth is exempt from the estate tax, so their heirs get that money for free.

Eliminating the estate tax will cost $269 billion over 10 years. Then the winners in this scheme will reinvest their newly found tax savings by opening factories and businesses and giving pay raises to their workers!

Of course, there will be budget cuts to programs that help the poor children, families and seniors in an attempt to demonstrate fiscal responsibility. Trump’s tax-cut proposal would eliminate the state and local tax deduction and may even take away the tax deductibility of 401(k) accounts, effectively raising taxes for millions of families.

There is absolutely no reason to think that working people’s wages will go up as wealthy people’s taxes go down — it didn’t happen under Reagan and it won’t happen now. The Massachusetts Budget and Policy Center reports that “Ten percent of all Massachusetts income went to the highest-income one percent of households in 1979. In 2014 it was 25 percent.”

Trickle-down economics didn’t work for Reagan or George W. Bush. Both of those presidents discovered that cutting revenue doesn’t actually increase revenue. Both Reagan and Bush increased taxes when faced with rising deficits.

The Trump tax-cut package will add $1.5 trillion to the deficit over the next 10 years. That’s a lot of roads, bridges and stormwater infrastructure that won’t be built. That’s Meals on Wheels, Head Start and fuel assistance programs shrinking as the need increases.

This plan won’t result in “better jobs, higher wages & greater opportunity for the forgotten men & women of this country,” as Sanders tweeted. It will put the American dream out of reach for even more of our friends and neighbors.

“Working families need #TaxReform & the time is now”? This isn’t tax reform, Ivanka. It is the Trump inheritance protection plan.

If the president and his family really cared about working families, they would pay their fair share. If Congress really cared about an economy that works for everyone, it would invest in education and infrastructure.

And, I’m sorry Mr. President. It’s not even the biggest tax cut in history. Obama signed that in 2012.

Clare Higgins, of Northampton, a former mayor of the city, is executive director of the nonprofit Community Action! of the Franklin, Hampshire and North Quabbin Regions. She can be reached at opinion@gazettenet.com.