AMHERST — Amherst’s tree warden and town planners have given permission for a developer to remove several trees, including a large northern catalpa, to make way for a mixed-use project on South East Street.
At an Aug. 27 joint hearing, Tree Warden Alan Snow said even though it was difficult to say the “charismatic” catalpa tree should come down, it is important to know when a tree is in decline.
The Public Shade Tree Committee has advised against removal of the trees, but Snow said his objective is to maintain a healthy and balanced tree canopy with diverse specimens and age classes.
“We will be planting trees for the next generation to enjoy at this spot,” Snow said.
Planners, in a 5-1 vote, agreed with the removal of the trees at the 133 and 143 South East St. properties, where two single-family homes will be demolished. The ultimate decision will rest with Town Manager Paul Bockelman, who can endorse the decision or override it, a power he is given based on two written appeals objecting to the trees being cut down.
Planning Board member Maria Chao said she understands the loss of the trees, but that the project, known as South East Court, is in a perfect location to enhance the neighborhood, and with a bus stop will also promote walking.
“We’re in so desperate need of housing and diversity and density in areas that we’ve earmarked as village centers,” Chao said.
Proposed by Amir Mikhchi, the three-story, L-shaped building will feature commercial space for two retail stores totaling 1,200 square feet on the ground floor and 62 residential units.
The lone board member to vote against the removal of the trees was Michael Birtwistle, who said he was moved by the idea that the catalpa tree and others are public property and valued by townspeople.
“It seems to me we’re being asked to provide development opportunities at the expense of an environmental asset to the town, and I’m uncomfortable with doing that,” Birtwistle said.
But he added that the area is in the village center and appropriate for development.
Board member Christine Gray-Mullen said the trees going away will be a loss, but the public way will be improved with new trees and a seating area.
If the trees do come down, Mikhchi will be required to provide financial compensation to the town.
Scott Merzbach can be reached at smerzbach@gazettenet.com.
