Joan Axelrod-Contrada
Joan Axelrod-Contrada

“Never again.”

That was my position on caregiving after Fred died. Two words. No footnotes. No exceptions.

Maybe some of us make declarations like that after a chapter of life has taken more out of us than we expected to give. Never again will I let a job consume me. Never again will I lose myself in a relationship. Never again will I put everybody else first.

Mine was caregiving.

Long before caregiving had entered my vocabulary, I was a 19-year-old happily singing along with Labelle’s “Lady Marmalade.” The racy French refrain —“Voulez-vous coucher avec moi?”— got me singing a little louder, smiling a little wider. 

Years later, Patti LaBelle came roaring back into my life with “New Attitude.” Instead of staying frozen in “Lady Marmalade,” she moved into another phase of her career and found a new sound.

Apparently, I could change my tune, too. My new attitude after Fred died was basically a barricade. I’d spent years watching the man I loved fade away while I tried to keep the household, appointments, crises and myself from flying apart. By the end, caregiving had swallowed so much of my life that I couldn’t imagine willingly stepping into that role again.

But those of us who enter relationships later in life can’t exactly pretend the caregiving question won’t come up. Bodies age. Health problems happen. Eventually, we have to figure out what we owe the person we love — and what we still owe ourselves. 

Then my boyfriend, the Poet, had surgery.

What followed was a difficult three-month recovery. He lived an hour away, with nowhere for me to stay. Long-distance driving was not exactly my superpower. Back home, I had two dogs, writing projects and an Airbnb that did not run itself.

Suddenly “Never again” was being put to the test.

The Poet, however, made things easier in a way I hadn’t expected.

He didn’t ask me to come rescue him. A local friend drove him to and from surgery. He didn’t plead with me to make the hour-long trip. He didn’t suggest that a devoted girlfriend would somehow overcome the distance, the driving, the dogs, the Airbnb and everything else in her life.

He was the opposite of demanding. And, funny thing, that endeared him to me. There is something wonderfully attractive about a person who needs help but doesn’t assume you are the help.

Because I didn’t feel conscripted, I wanted to give more. That surprised me. 

My old caregiving reflex had always been simple: What needs to be done?

Then I did it.

For years afterward, I lumped all caregiving together. What I remembered most viscerally from Fred’s illness was the hands-on nursing — the part that left me feeling as if my own life had disappeared. Never again seemed like the only protection I had.

But caregiving wasn’t one indivisible job. I could pick and choose.

I could listen. I could encourage. I could help the Poet think through questions for his doctors. I could notice when something didn’t sound right and urge him to follow up. I actually liked being an advocate and cheerleader.

What I didn’t have to do was become the nurse. That distinction felt enormous.

Now a better question emerged: What kind of help am I best at providing?

And sometime during those three months, I stumbled onto the magic phrase that gave voice to my newest attitude. “Call your doctor.”

The Poet would describe some pain, symptom or setback over the phone. My old reflex might have sent me scrambling to Google, trying to diagnose a man 60 miles away.

Instead: “Call your doctor.”

What a concept.

Four syllables, and I could care about him without earning an honorary medical degree. 

Years of caregiving had trained me to jump in. Anticipate. Organize. Watch for trouble. Those skills had once been necessary, but apparently the invisible cape was still hanging in my closet.

The Poet didn’t need a superhero. He needed a girlfriend.

I could listen when he was scared, speak up when I was useful and still go home to my dogs, my writing, my guests and my own life. 

“Never again” had sounded pretty good after Fred died. But it turned out I didn’t need a barricade. I needed a guardrail.

And when the Poet starts describing a medical problem neither of us has any business diagnosing?

Patti, take it away.

New attitude.

“Call your doctor.”

Joan Axelrod-Contrada is a writer who lives in Florence with her two dogs. Sign up for her free quarterly newsletter—complete with links to bonus content such as music videos and fun facts — by emailing her at joanaxelrodcontrada@gmail.com.