The Gazette’s recent coverage of the development of St Mary’s property in Northampton has been helpful and thorough for our city residents. Many negative remarks have been circulating about the proposed building for the former parking lot. The building would cover the lower level of the lot near the road and swallow up the hill to the back of the rectory and church buildings.

We have been told that the rectory is being reconstructed as an inn, but there is no plan for the reuse of the church. It should be remembered that in the past it was used as a venue for concerts for local choral groups because of its outstanding acoustics. Also, the large first floor hall with a stage and three individual rooms is a possible site for various community meetings and events.

It is certainly in the best interest of the city’s historical district to decide on the development of the church before building an oversized, ugly building that creates a tunnel effect on State Street, interferes with traffic and parking, and is detrimental to the Edwards Church. The rear of the proposed five-story building as seen from Smith College when driving down Elm Street hides the view of downtown.

A positive and simple decision about the grotto on the rectory lawn could be made. Since it was built by parishioners with some relatives still in town, perhaps the stones could be given to St. Mary’s Cemetery.

There is no doubt that a smaller building could be built on the property to enhance the residential needs in Northampton, but the appropriateness of the present building is outrageous.

Mary McMahon

Northampton